Ocean Echo
by puppet10

Comment:
I like the placement of the shell - I just wish it were a bit larger. As the shot is now it is hard to see the detail and texture of the shell. =4

Golden Maple Leaf
by evmariedogs

Comment:
The lighting on the tip of the leaf and the right of the chain is a bit too bright for me. I think the shot would have been better off of a table surface - perhaps hanging from a tree instead - as it is now the shot is a bit too flat for my taste = 4

TX-Tours
by Frank Beckman

Comment:
I am not sure what to do with this - I like the original idea and play on words - but I wish that the shot had included more of the actual "texture" of some of the items so that it wasn't such a flat picture - real grapes for the wine, maybe some rocks for the caverns... I will give it a 4

the texture of fog
by ritaard

Comment:
This is a good capture of the dog in motion - but I wish he was further in the frame and not running off to the right side as it draws my eye to much to that direction. This was a stretch for me in if it meet the challenge. I originally scored it a 4 - I would rather have seen a shot of the wave meeting the shore where more texture was visible, but I checked with my local weather guru who assured me that fog does have texture so I am bumping up the score to a 6.

Velvet Antlers
by bobgaither

Comment:
nice photo, but it seems more incidental that you have captured the velvet antlers here. I just don't see the texture as the main focus - but give you points for getting a good shot = 4

Windpower
by Pete02t

Comment:
nice picture - would have scored more highly if the car was not there.

Classic Rot
by Gotcha

Comment:
I like this shot - I wonder what it would look like in b/w?

Rest
by miller

Comment:
This is great - please do a tutorial when the challenge is finished! = 10

If These Walls Could Talk...
by BigSmiles

Comment:
nice shot - did you see what this looks like in b/w? just wondering how it would be - still get's a 10 from me :)

Aracnophobia
by kristie380

Comment:
meeting challenge = 5 photo quality = 5. nice colors here. good quality captured in the spider. nice job! total = 10