light's ebb
by aelith

Comment:
I like the dead tree and would have liked to see more of it. I feel conflicted between saying it's too dark and being just right. Were you attempting to "set a mood"? Maybe a dramatic view of the tree would help. 6 Swash

Christmas colors
by kevinswope

Comment:
Nice colors, but where is your focal point? This might have worked better with more distance and a little zoom (distance increases your focal depth, too) A less obtuse angle might have helped this, too. (Straight on might be boring, but it will be fully in focus) 5 Swash

Green Cheese
by Chaszmyr

Comment:
Cool idea, but extremely grainy. Sorry, but I just can't think of anything else to add. 5 Swash

Birds Eye View
by spiderman

Comment:
Kinda grainy, possibly you might want to consider turning off your digital zoom, too (I need to as well!) Sharpness is pretty good, esp. considering the grain, so you have a steady hand. Interest, for me is on the lower side. Sorry, 5 Swash

Up in the Clouds
by jab119

Comment:
The distraction on the left really turns me off this pic. IMO, it needed to be either more fully in the shot, or better yet, fully out of it. The clouds and distorted sun are fairly nice, but not very striking. There's an odd greenish cast in the upper middle/right that doesn't look right/good, too. Sorry, 5 Swash

A Splash of Color
by Rackat

Comment:
Gosh, this is soooo colorful! Very nicely stopped action. The colorful background both confuses and adds interest to this (usually great, but cliche) shot. I really like this and your addition really makes this photo much more unique and very, very striking! 9 Swash

Abstract Martini
by Alecia

Comment:
Wow! Great color, very nice set up. Really minor things in the glass/water that seem somehow out of place, but still it's not enough to harm a really cool view. How about a 9? Swash

Happy Holidays!
by timj351

Comment:
Great color and a very steady hand! Feels alot like christmas. There's something about the setup/framing that I just can't put my finger on, but it's not enough to really kill your score (esp. since I can't figure out what it is!) 9 Swash

Hanging On
by welcher

Comment:
While there were several this week I really like, this is my favorite! I just love the cracked ice on the branches. The drip off the leaf is great too. Great color!!!! An easy 10 in my book! Swash

Mary Lee's Corvette
by kendall

Comment:
I like this edit better than the DeviantArt version. This is brighter and the color comes out better. Very nice job! I've seen quite a few concert photos, most don't turn out very well, this did. With minimal lighting, you stopped her hair in mid swing. Mary looks very sharp and crisp. I'm going with a 9 here, but might change my mind for a 10. Very nice! Swash