Whisper in the air
by Dufus

Comment:
The coloring and moodiness of the sky combined with the profile view of the model is good along with the clarity of the picture. The only thing I would suggest improving is the position of her back arm. Since it is a silhouette, her arm blends into her body and makes her look wider than I feel she is.

Play on words.
by parrothead

Comment:
Nice picture if the kitty.

Sleeping Beauty
by menardmam

Comment:
I don't feel comfortable commenting on this one because I saw your outakes and feel, personally, that you lost the anonymity required for an unbiased vote.

We're all born naked
by Leok

Comment:
Funny that this idea was just used in the last challenge and someone still questioned if it was real. Almost flawless execution. I like how the model's arms are within the frame, it adds to the unreality of the picture. The only nit is the skirt. The waistband showing against the frame sorta ruins the effect. Bumping up because of the work it took to create this.

~~~ Eve~~~
by Jutilda

Comment:
I like these out of the box pictures. This picture seems to be to balanced ( I think that's the first time I've ever had to say that). Both objects carry the same visual weight. The viewer's eyes bounce back and forth between the two. What would help is for the photographer to decide which object is to be the subject and then use the other object to reinforce that idea. To me, this is a nice idea that was poorly executed.

Time for Me
by CalliopeKel

Comment:
Very classic look. The blinds, bottles and soothing blues make this easy to look at. The pose matches the surroundings. The only thing that, to me, causes this to have a sub 10 score is the post processing. The outline seems to harsh. This would have been great with a soft focus feel to it.

Red
by TooCool

Comment:
The use of the backlight really helps to separate the model from the background. The pose has a classic portrait look. I don't think it fits well with this challenge but would fit well with another type. There seems to be a color problem in the picture. Her face has a greenish tint and the color on her forearms is uneven. This might have been caused by a slight underexposure.

From a Crysallid
by mpemberton

Comment:
Beautiful shades of blue.

Nature's perfect design
by DogAngel

Comment:
The coloring is exceptional. I like the contrast of her light skin, red hair and muted setting. Her pose looks uncomfortable.

Despair
by jmlelii

Comment:
I like the twisted pose and the lowered head and the light treatment generally. I mourn the loss of detail in her shoulder and hand.