Author Thread
Post actions
Congratulations on the blue, a new personal best, and an average of just under 8! You have started with an excellent still life (with hand) and you have done an excellent job in mocking up an excellent Bon Appetit cover. Nicely done.
Post actions
Post actions
Thought this was the most real looking of the bunch. Really well done, Mary Ann!!
Post actions
this is brilliantly done. Excellent score!!!
Post actions
Congratulations! My top score for this challenge. It all came together--the photo, the fonts, the layout.
Post actions
I thought I was looking at a "real" magazine cover! Did you do this for a living at some point? Was going to be Blue from the beginning. Congrats Mary Ann!
Post actions
Congrats on your first place win! Highly professional image, 9 from me.
Post actions
"Thank you so much for the wonderful comments and the generous score. This was a lot of fun to put together."
Post actions
wow! That is a fabulous cover, Mary Ann. Congratulations, on a well deserved Blue!
Post actions
Absolutely superb! Not only are your a super photographer but also a super graphic designer.
Post actions
Congrats! Long time since i saw such a high score. Great job!
Post actions
Wow! Look at the number of comments during voting --
Post actions
Very well done, Mary Ann! Your cover is beautiful, and that cake looks delicious! Congrats on the blue, and a new PB!!
Post actions
The clear winner from the git go
Post actions
Congrats on the blue - and the great score!
Post actions
Congrats - so well deserved!
Post actions
SO close to an 8! Congrats!
Post actions
Wow!!!! Look at that score. I had a feeling it would be a very high scoring photo.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Looks authentic, and I would buy that magazine. Nicely done. Top pick.
Post actions
wow, you really nailed it.
Post actions
This is the best one by far, beautifully photographed, fantastic light, everything from the composition to the sprinkling of the icing sugar, the wonderful looking cake and even the font is superb...very very professional, I'm guessing it's Mary Ann, my top pick!
Post actions
This is basically perfect. Beautiful toning on this!
Post actions
I do believe this is my favorite. I have gone back over to add my text and have fallen in love with this one. You did a quite professional job on this cover. I gave you a 10 on this one.
Post actions
Almost looks like the real thing. Good imitation.
Post actions
Figginess. Not just for pudding anymore. So well designed!
Post actions
Truly looks like a magazine cover. Well done.
Post actions
I would buy this issue and make all the fig recipes
Post actions
Excellent job all around!!
Post actions
Wow, the blue ribbon.
Post actions
Post actions
Front page stuff for sure. This really looks like a front page from the magazine. Well done. If I had ANY nit it would be the overly red/saturated hand.
Post actions
Splendid. Even the fonts are perfect.
Chocolate Fig Cake
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
