The Oculus
by Rikki

Comment:
Although the picture is small (you should resize the longest side to 640, the composition is very interesting. 5

City of the Future
by gudbjargarson

Comment:
I've looked at this photo a couple of times. I like the lighting (especially on the clouds from the large tower), although I wish that we saw some reflection of the lights in the water. Also, the pincushioning could be fixed with perspective in PS. 6

Astral Projection
by moodville

Comment:
I enjoy this photo, but just in my opinion I don't like the skull in the middle. I think you could almost do this without anything there. 6

Walking on Water
by kmbr2001

Comment:
Great use of negative space. I like the b&w conversion, and the grain works. 6

Space. The Final Frontier
by CorySmith

Comment:
The lighting is very good in this photo. Interesting use of the marble/glass ball. Picture though doesn't relaly draw me into itself as I'm trying to find a focal point to it. You used negative space, but I think it needs to be more to make the ball more of a focus.

Solaris
by LevT

Comment:
I find myself trying to figure out what is in the background as I look through the bubbles. Clarity and color make the picture interesting. The implied triangle between the 3 larger bubbles makes the composition. I would though clone out some of the smaller bubbles to give more clarity to the image overall. 6

Middle earth
by Stagolee

Comment:
I like the silhouette. Two things hurt this picture, first being that it is easy to see that this is a toy/model being shot, secondly the light in the background. The branches are what really help the shot. 6

Interdimensional Visitor
by amber

Comment:
The picture is not bad for the darkness and the softness, since that is helping to establish the reality of the alien. I guess when I look at the picture, I just can't buy the eye points. If they are really in the original photograph, then forgive me, but they seem to be dodges in post processing. However, I still like the photo overall. 6

Starman
by sher

Comment:
Being a toy will not help, but you have done as much as I think is possible to transform it from a simple toy that could be done to make it look realistic. Coloration in the photo is good, lighting I think is excellent as is the DOF. 6

Natural Wonder
by pitsaman

Comment:
How can anyone not like Arches National Park there in UT. This picture would do better if it was tied closer to the theme of the challenge. As it is one of the more famous 'natural' places in this world, it doesn't seem to fit as much in another one. But it is a good composition, and you did have to hike to get up to it, so 6