The Interchangeable
by spiderman

Comment:
Like the close up, showing the scratches on the wood and metal and the rustiness. Also prefer shots which close up and make an abstract of the picture rather than show the whole item, well, depends what the subject matter is, but for things like this. Nice.

Time of Death: 12:11
by rdesai

Comment:
I like the composition and how clearly the dirt on the watch face is visible.

Atom 153
by boyte1

Comment:
Nice shot. Could be a postcard in a toy museum :)

Broken childhood memories
by prodigal havoc

Comment:
Love the idea - composition within the frame could be improved - wonder if you could move your position to get rid of the blue house in the background? And to show all of the top of the frame?

Still Beautiful...
by annelizabeth

Comment:
Love the image, but too dark at top left - otherwise would have marked even higher. Beautiful faded pink colour to the rose.

Centenarian
by autool

Comment:
I like the focus on the handle of the tool and the visibility of the wear and tear, and I also love that it only has three main colours, rich bronze, silver and black. I would like a tiny bit more black space at the top of the image.

All the Marbles
by Kathyc

Comment:
This is fantastic - I adore the colours and the way you've got low down to take the shot. The only regret is the way the pouch is just clipped at the top and the leather tie at the right. The carpet works well as a background too. It leaves me wishing that I still had my marbles (!) and could play for penny chews!

Having now looked regularly at all 7 of my score 9 choices, I have decided that this one is definitely my absolute favourite and am upping my score to a ten. I know it's not perfect, technically, because of the slight clipping at two edges, but I do love it.

It made me Happy
by alex

Comment:
Needs rotating, I know that's obvious but I can't even appreciate this one without twisting my head too far to be comfortable which doesn't make me want to score it highly. Also seems too faded at roof of car end and too dark at front of car end. Sorry!

Homeward Bound
by connie

Comment:
I really love this, the way that it's a model yet does have an air of reality and grittiness to it. I like the composition too. It just clicks for me.

Nobody home
by normw

Comment:
I like this but find the top half of the frame adds nothing (for me) and I'd look at what it's like cropped into a squarer shape, losing some of the top.