Fun in the Snow
by Kneeforu

Comment:
Cropped a bit too tightly for my personal taste but this is a good shot, good colours, good bokeh and good sharpness.

Through the Bridge
by fotodude

Comment:
Good idea but not executed. To me at least it looks like nothing is in focus in this shot and that is its biggest weaknes IMO. I like that it´s BW though and the tones in it and the centered framing works well here. Just get it in focus next time and you will have a great shot.

Anxiety
by DefyTime

Comment:
Good shot, great colours and great DOF but I don´t find the subject particularly interesting, after looking at this image for 1 second I have seen everything I need to see. To be clear though I like this image, I bet it would look good in a catalouge for wine.

rosebud
by JC_Homola

Comment:
It´s a good shot, good exposure and colours but what drag it down IMO is the busy backround. Just the straws at the bottom would have been enough for my taste. Anyway, like the shot.

One For The Road
by autool

Comment:
It´s a good Idea with good bokeh but a little tight for my opinion, the glass ever so barelyl fits in the frame. Good shot anyways, good luck in this challenge.

Shell on the Beach
by biggood53

Comment:
It´s not a bad shot, good composition but I think this would look much better about 1 stop less exposed. However, it´s IMO not on topic for this challenge since there is no Bokeh.

Concerto
by ellamay

Comment:
Great shot, love everything about it. However in this challenge, a bit off topic in my personal opinion since the backround is too busy for my taste and doesn´t really add to the photo. In short, if this was a "wildlife" challenge I would have given it a 9 but in this challenge I gave it a 8. Hope you do well.

The Players Edge
by GolferDDS

Comment:
I can see this is validated so I know this is authentic but the problem with the "ball" is that in my opinion it looks too fake, it´s lit too differently from the backround to make it work. Keep in mind that I am not saying I could do better, I can´t but then again I would not submit a shot that looks like this.

Other than that it´s a decent shot, nice composition and colours, I gave it a 5.

hekobokeh
by LevT

Comment:
Very good shot, spot on in this challenge. I would have given it a 10 if but not for a couple of details. The dark spot up in the left corner grabs too much attention and the angle of wich you took this photo is too steep for my taste, the raindrop behind the one in focus blends too much together. Anyway, love this shot, gave it a 9.

Learn to be nice, not nasty
by steinar

Comment:
Brilliant photograph, among the best portraits I have ever seen, especially like the 1:1 ratio crop instead of the 3:2 you got out of your camera, good call on that one. I didn´t vote in this challenge since I have been rather busy but I would have given it a 10 and as far as I am concerned, the best photo won this challenge.