pre-digital
by queen 91

Comment:
There is quite a bit of pixelation going on in this, I'm not certain if it's due to re-sizing or resolution or what. also if you boost the cameras up above the background cloth it might help a great deal to hide it in the photo. (a lint brush is a must) - good luck

Stopped In It's Tracks
by timj351

Comment:
This is my favorite photo for this challenge. I love the color. My only comment would be that the sky on the right side is just a little too light. But I think its because of the white background. With a matting & frame, Perfect. - 10

The Original
by CreativeFlyPhoto

Comment:
Very clever. I wouldn't know how to improve on this. - 10

Happy Days
by lecalan

Comment:
I love this shot. I love it in B/W. - 9

1872 Cannon
by npage

Comment:
Perfect subject for this challenge. I'm not sure if it's slightly blured or if I'm just getting old. - great shot

1896
by arnit

Comment:
wow, we're not in Kansas anymore Toto. - this is beautiful. 10

A/C
by MrsKro

Comment:
You know, I love this shot, its perfect in every way. But the white background against the white background of the browser window makes this look too bland. (It's not your photo). this has bothered me on several photos in this challenge. Not much we can fix about that, until we get it to the frame store. - 9

Grandpa's Ice Wagon
by Niten

Comment:
I love this. It is just a little over exposed for my taste but still in my top 10

(c) 1897
by malapropam

Comment:
wow, the real mcCoy. The red ribbon is a nice touch. I do see some of the background cloth catching light in several places, but not too critical. nice lighting.

The Interchangeable
by spiderman

Comment:
Well, this is a difficult shot to critique because I like it. But by changing the angle of the lighting to cut back on some of the glare off the stock lock, you might just loose some of the contrast that also gives this it's character.....Hmmmm. I'd love to see some of the out takes of this shot, and the many combinations you went through to settle in to this.