Dear Deer
by Mona

Comment:
You will realise by now that you may have missed the point of the challenge - to explore different aspect ratios and to choose your composition to suit. Here, whilst you have met the challenge in so much as one side is 240 px, the standard aspect ratio means you simply have a very small image. It's a sweet deer, though :)

The Yard
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
Well suited to the aspect ratio. This is actually one of the few photos in the challenge where I forget the photo is an odd ratio - there is so much to see, my eyes dance all around the frame. Good entry.

Perseverance
by jomari

Comment:
interesting scene, soundly composed. There doesn't seem to be any point where focus is sharp, though.

I opened two gifts this morning. They were my eyes
by pgirish007

Comment:
Excellent scene for the challenge. The composition seems just a tad off - I wonder if you cropped in from the right if it would have more balance?

Mountains at Sunset
by MargaretNet

Comment:
Very nice indeed, and perfect for the challenge.

transit
by tnun

Comment:
Doesn't really work for me either as a conceptual/metaphor, or as a straight nature photo.

Future Motion
by Cory

Comment:
Expertly done for the type of image. Could imagine this in a magazine or as part of an ad.

Middle Fork Two
by mpeters

Comment:
The composition is good, but I find my eyes straining towards the light rather than being gently led there. The dark 2/3rds of he photo lack contrast and have a faintly murky feel. Personally I feel you have gone a bit too slow on the shutter - whilst it can be good to smooth out the water a bit, here there is no sense of movement at all.

Terra
by Yo_Spiff

Comment:
Really rather cool. Effective.

Glenfinnan
by Pangurban

Comment:
been there - you've done it proud.