Silencio
by kiwiness

Comment:
I really like the different elements in this shot as they seem to tell a story and elude to more that whats in the photo. The contrast, and grainy quality really add to the emotive feel of this shot... my vote is a 7

Old Pier
by IceRock

Comment:
Very nice capture. The detail and DOF is great. I think either more fill flash to bring out the bottom of the frame, or less fill flash to de-emphasize the top may have worked a bit better for me. Nice shot nonetheless... I vote a 7

As Life Passes
by Artyste

Comment:
I really like this shot as one of my favorites of the challenge. The color pallete and saturation give this a very emotive quality. It also has a nice candid feel not present in many of the other entries. Great use of DOF and composition to emphasize your subject... I vote an 8

Somewhere in Time
by skewsme

Comment:
Good stuff. Creative angle and subject that answers the challenge theme perfectly. Technicals all look good... my vote is a 7

A Beautiful View
by idnic

Comment:
I really like the skewed composition and pose of your subject. The soft lighting is very nice. Some shadows being cast but still nice overall... my vote is a 7

Through the Square window
by MAK

Comment:
Not sure what your artistic goal was with the subject. It gives me a bit of a "Clockwork Orange" flashback. But anyways, technically the shot is good for the most part. Saturation and color temperature seem a tad overdone and on the warm side. The thing that detracts for me most is the post-pro evident around the man and edges of the subject: Less photograph, more graphic design kinda feel. Regardless, I like the composition and creative direction you took with this.... I vote a 7

A Moment to Herself
by sir_bazz

Comment:
Very nice B&W here. The natural lighting and shadows really give this a soft, emotive feel. I would have prefered to see more crop to remove more of the dark left side since it gives the composition an unbalanced feel that does not appear intentional. Nice shot nonetheless... I vote a 7

Looking into the Treehouse
by Pedro

Comment:
The look of curiosity and intrepidness in the childs face make this shot great. The detail, focus, and technicals are good. My vote is a 7

Through a Glass Darkly
by xianart

Comment:
Very artistic interpretation of the challenge theme. I like the emotive quality here and the different elements you've incorporated... my vote is a 7

Haleluja!
by Bolti

Comment:
Very cool and creative shot. I would have preferred to see a tad more desaturation outside of the fram eto really make the subject pop. Nice shot nonetheless... I vote 7