Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Post actions
Dramatic image. Nicely done.
Post actions
amazing shot, picture could off been a bit brighter
Post actions
Post actions
This would have been a great entry for the lone tree challenge too! Nice sky and background.
Post actions
This tree has seen a lot of them. Nice shot of a rugged tree looking over a beautiful landscape.
Post actions
Nice lone tree. Good back lighting from the sky.
Post actions
Well captured and presented.
Post actions
Post actions
the sky seems a little dark for a silhouette, but it's great subject matter :)
Post actions
It's fascinating. I think I would have liked a little more detail though, the rock and the tree look like they'd be even more interesting with it.
Post actions
great shot - the compesition could be better (diff. crop)
Post actions
Post actions
Excellent silhouette. I love how its a dark image but there are still so many details visible.
Post actions
It's to dark in the foreground. You really should've took advantage of the Advanced rules for this.
Post actions
An unusual image which really captures the esscence of the faiding light of dusk. Well done and good luck for the rest of the challenge.
Post actions
This is a little dark to me but what great subject matter! That tree on the edge of a very high cliff, surviving, wow.
Post actions
Sunrise and sunset have to be really crisp for me. This could have been crisper
Post actions
Post actions
dark dusk... maybe too dark... 4 sorry for that ;)
Post actions
Wonderful single tree and soft colors.
Post actions
Nice sky, but too dark in bottom of shot. This is a great concept with the tree hanging on the side of the cliff, but you almost can't see it.
Post actions
Interpretation of Topic: Good Choice
Post actions
This is a powerful shot. Love the tree.
Post actions
Post actions
Great power in this silhouette. The line of orange light seems to pierce its heart. Great sky, though I'd like a little more detail in the lower half.
Post actions
nice silhouette, I like the colors
Post actions
a spirit tree. the light in this (at least, on this monitor) is fabulous. Getting it to print out on paper just right might be an interesting challenge. If you haven't tried printing yet I hope you will consider it.
Post actions
Post actions
Really nice use of the silhouette
Post actions
This is really cool. Looks like Arkansas' Mount Magizine.
Post actions
I like the way this tree looks as if it's about to go to sleep
Post actions
What a great, interesting, unique tree, great subject and location.
Post actions
even though it is dark...your colors still show through...very good
Post actions
Post actions
i like the dusky feel of this, but it seems like it could use a little something else. maybe some dodging in the sky? im not sure
Post actions
Amazing how some of these trees can cling to life in the most inhospitable places. Nicely composed.
Post actions
A bit too dark but very nice picture!
Post actions
Good shot but maybe a little too dark.
Post actions
Good shot but a bit too dark for me.
Post actions
Great capture, however the centered composition doesn't work well here IMHO.
Post actions
A little to bland for me but great subject!
Post actions
looks like a lonely tree!
Post actions
Really like the image, think it may have been a good contender for B&W conversion.
Post actions
Post actions
This doesn't really grab me as a sunset shot or a silhouette or a tree shot - it's kind of in-between all of them :(
Post actions
This is actually a nice shot. On my screen, I would have liked to have just a tad more detail in the mid-ground area. 6
Post actions
very nice shot, great light and composition
Post actions
A little dark, but very nice.
Post actions
Maybe lighten a little bit. Kind of too dark.
Post actions
It's pretty... Really.. it's pretty. And it's sharp. It's just somehow not very exciting to me and I can't figure out why.
Post actions
Normally, I dont like the dark and grey tones, but I think it adds to this image. Nice composition.
Post actions
Post actions
Post actions
Nice shot but perhaps a little dark?
Post actions
Nice sihloette, perhaps a tad dark overall, but I really like it!
Post actions
This shot is so nice. You can feel the quiet. Pretty.
Post actions
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
