Author Thread
03/24/2004 12:10:27 AMPost actions
[Critique Club]
Composition - The background is distacting, it would have been better if had been blurred or replaced. Centered is good, but also normal. Size could have been bigger (up to 640 largest size).
Technical Quality - I think this could have been edited to a higher quality. Lighting is good, could have been sharpened a little, contrast could have been boosted. Red eye could have been eliminated.
Meets the Challenge - check.
Creativity - Nice capture of the expression, funny.
Overall - Funny picture, but could have had a higher quality.
Comments Made During the Challenge
03/16/2004 11:03:10 PMPost actions
Too posed and artificial to really make me wonder what is off screen.
03/16/2004 10:48:24 PMPost actions
sorry...colors are dull, there is red-eye, and the top of the hair being chopped off is distracting.
03/15/2004 07:35:25 AMPost actions
03/14/2004 09:46:17 PMPost actions
Maybe the foggy look is due to the finger-in-light-socket experiment.
03/14/2004 03:23:05 PMPost actions
Funny picture..great hair, but exposure is poor
03/14/2004 02:21:17 PMPost actions
You submitted a photo w/Red Eye to a photography contest.
hahahahhaa.....
03/13/2004 03:11:40 PMPost actions
Cute picture. Kinda blurry and a little foggy but very funny. 8
03/13/2004 02:50:01 AMPost actions
...or perhaps, good morning :)
03/13/2004 01:19:45 AMPost actions
a very good idea for this challenge...the red eye hurts you here...as soes the overall washed out look of the shot
03/13/2004 01:08:46 AMPost actions
The lighting makes this a very flat image. Perhaps some more contrast would help.
03/12/2004 03:54:54 PMPost actions
Interesting expression but too pale and too much red-eye
03/12/2004 11:48:39 AMPost actions
the redeye is distracting, the pic is low on contrast too
03/12/2004 08:04:27 AMPost actions
Too bad for the redeye. Shot needs lots of work
03/12/2004 04:41:02 AMPost actions
hahahaha hahahahahahah very funny.7
03/11/2004 12:01:41 PMPost actions
Exposure and focus seem a bit off, and read eye really distracts from the photo but the expression is great.
03/11/2004 11:31:15 AMPost actions
good idea,but flash ruined shot. An inexpensive wat to create diffused lighting is natural light thry window, or lamp w/o its shade. This shot could use some contrast adjustments in a photo program to rid the gray overlay.
Photographer found comment helpful.
03/11/2004 07:50:29 AMPost actions
Good idea, but the picture quality is leaves a bit to be desired.
03/10/2004 07:35:22 PMPost actions
good but you can get rid of the red eye
03/10/2004 04:55:13 PMPost actions
Great reaction shot. The red eye even works in this picture. :) - 6
03/10/2004 03:53:38 PMPost actions
Made me laugh. Is he hanging upside down?
03/10/2004 03:36:18 PMPost actions
NIce expression and mad hair. The picture quality is a bit flat though, lacking cripness, clarity and colour depth.
03/10/2004 03:14:34 PMPost actions
get a point for the surprise, but the pic is not really good, lightening, colours, saturation... sorry doesn't charm me...
03/10/2004 11:08:17 AMPost actions
too bad about the red eye. Love his hair.
03/10/2004 12:40:09 AMPost actions
cute subject, low photo quality