Author Thread
Post actions
Greetings from the Critique Club.
Post actions
Post actions
Great work, a definate wall hanger or coffee table book. Very stiking.
Post actions
this looks like my desktop!
Post actions
Congratulations on the 8th place! Great shot!
Post actions
Good work Terje. Nicely balanced compositoin.
Post actions
Another case where I let the beauty of the shot rule my vote - not so desolate it seems to me.
Post actions
Stunning image - just beautiful. Congrats on your top 10 finish!
Post actions
terje: Congratulations on your 8th place finish. An awesome image.
Post actions
Wowsa, nice shot. More serene than desolate, to me, but the voters have spoken :-) Hell of a shot either way.
Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
great image, I don't see desolation though. more serene than desolate.
Post actions
Post actions
a beautiful shot that leaves me feeling calm and peaceful...
Post actions
BEAUTIFULL
Post actions
So calm, so quiet, and so beautiful, in a desolate eort of way.....
Post actions
beautiful but not sure if its really desolate
Post actions
very pleasing image - one of my favorites for the challenge.
Post actions
An enticing form and color study. 8
Post actions
Wow...this is beautiful. 10!
Post actions
a stunning shot enhanced by DOF to illistrate a vast emptiness
Post actions
Looks beautiful, not desolate.
Post actions
Beautiful...my favorite of the challenge! Great job!
Post actions
Beautiful pic but I have a certain picture of desolation in my head and this isnt it >.<
Post actions
I already voted a while ago, now I'm back for commenting. I gave this picture a 9. I think it conveys the meaning well.
Post actions
Very nice and one of the more desolate pics in the challenge.
Post actions
STUNNING! this photograph is not only well executed but has found the beauty of desolation.
Post actions
I love the smoothness of the water vs the roughness of the rocks. Excellent colors in the horizon. 8
Post actions
Nice! One of my top picks.
Post actions
too me this is peaceful not desolaate, however since the challenge is what does desolation to you, I am not letting this affect my vote for the challenge, but maybe others feel the same. the DoF on your shot is amazing and composition is great.
Post actions
Love this image. Gives one the true feeling of desolation. Well done.
Post actions
Nice shot. Very cool. Good work.
Post actions
Beautiful photograph, love the mist around the rocks.
Post actions
Comparative desolation: a filthy canal in Brooklyn on fire. Graffiti and stains on the walls of a burned out house. Children growing up in cockroach infested homes. Your photo looks like paradise to me. But we will say it is artistic desolation, OK? 8.
Post actions
Amazing shot, gorgeous color and contrast between the earth and sky. The large body of water in the background definitely gives it an appearance of a desolate area IMO. Simply gorgeous. Good luck! 8
Post actions
Beautiful view, magnificent desolation
Post actions
great long exposure...wonderful
Post actions
Mmm, I love smooth water.
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
Photographer found comment helpful.
