Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Concept: Unsure, is blurry and what detail is on left is muddled in the shadow.
Post actions
This is a lovely image with the subtle reflection, however as a silhouette, I feel ther is too much detail on display
Post actions
shouldn't a silhouette be the other way around? dark kid and lighter background?
Post actions
Nice, soft image in profile, but, it doesn't really meet the challenge of a backlit subject which appears solid and without much detail.
Post actions
I am not dure this is a silhouette as such but still a very nice image
Post actions
hmm... not really a silhouette, and its focus is soft.
Post actions
This image is more of a profile than a silhouette...pretty light though.
Post actions
I don't see this as a silouette to be honest. It's a good picture in it's own right but doesn't meet the challenge IMO.
Post actions
The lighting on the boy's face is very nice. I can't really tell what he is looking at though, its a little dark.
Post actions
Cute kid but you misunderstood the challenge apparently, too bad :(
Post actions
reflection not silhouette ??
Post actions
Post actions
fantastic image, with lots of ethos
Post actions
very nice.I really like the photo of the boy.What is in the left side of the photo?
Post actions
Is it my monitor? is there suppose to be something on the right that he's looking at?
Post actions
Post actions
Nice composition and a very cute subject! But not a silhouette.
Post actions
A cute photo, but not a silhouette. I am sure others have made the same comment. What I do see here is nice positioning of the subject. I like this composition, perhaps a bit sharper focus.
Post actions
Too much detail for a good silhouette. There are also some sharpness issues.
Post actions
Cute kid. Nice portrait. Unfortunately not a silhouette.
Post actions
I'm missing the Silhouette in this image. Please help me find it.
Post actions
I have to mark this low beacuse it does not meet the challnege.... very cute kid though!
Post actions
IMO this doesn't meet the silhouette challenge, theres too much detail visible in the main subject
Post actions
not a silhouette. Lacking in focus.
Post actions
The subject is realy a cute kid! Your picture isn't really a silhouette, the child is in profile but not silhouette.
Post actions
this is not a silhouette (I'm sure many others said that already) and it's not quite in focus
Post actions
Too much detail, change to white backround, meter it, increase two stops and try it again.
Post actions
i am not sure if I don't understand the challange or not but i don't see a silhouette here. I see a child with lots of shadows. sorry
Post actions
I'm sure you'll be told a lot, this is not a silhouette. It is almost rim-light. You'll see numerous examples of silhouettes in this challenge, but in short, the dominant subject is all or mostly black, and it's strength is in it's shape and form, not colors or surface features. Hope that helps. Keep at it! :)
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
