Author Thread Comments Made During the Challenge
Post actions
Nice use of b&w, I think I've seen a commercial like this, anway it is a nice twist
Post actions
This is just outstanding. I love the thought of the flatscreen as a window, and this is just such a cool picture. I wish it were color, though, so I could see the connections between all of the elements better.
Post actions
Post actions
Cool Idea. The contrast seems a little flat -- perhaps that's a monitor conflict (my machine vs yours)
Post actions
Nice idea -- clever side-step of color-matching issues by going grayscale.
Post actions
I could see Apple doing this. Very creative and well presented.
Post actions
I like it. Very well exposed. Looks like it could have used a little more depth of field. Nice composition. Well done.
Post actions
cannot tell what is advertised without the title---sorry
Post actions
A great idea, and seems well executed. B/W is a very odd choice here, though. The subject doesn't have the kind of tonal range that makes an interesting monochrome, and, since your product is a monitor, the missing color is a big negative.
Post actions
Awesome! I like that and your title. Works well and can even be an apple add.
Post actions
very clever and pretty well executed
Post actions
But what is it selling, the brand? It is really well done and imaginative.
Post actions
Post actions
B&W doesn't work very well with this picture...
Post actions
Hahahaa.. LOL. Wonderful spoof!
Post actions
Cute, but what are you selling?
Post actions
Very cool idea.. Wish this could have been more colorful..
Post actions
good god I hope you didn't break that nice looking monitor just for the picture!!!!
Post actions
very cool. Vines are a nice touch too
Post actions
I think I see the hand of a favorite photographer of mine in this one.
Post actions
If this really is an image on the screen arranged with real books, this is a technical masterpiece! I'm wondering why it's in black and white...
Post actions
Very creative, but does not encourage me to buy anything.
Post actions
Post actions
Cute, good concept, but I am not buying.....(What are you selling? besides humor) Photo 10 Advert 4 (probably me) Creativity 9 total 7
Post actions
although i am a fan of black and white, it would be more interesting in color in the case.
Post actions
Post actions
Great idea and you did it well.
Post actions
This is a neat concept! I like it. What puzzles me on this one is why you chose black and white? Good job!
Post actions
I think this might have been more appealling in color. Nice setup though
Post actions
Post actions
Interestly little idea here. Although as for selling me a MAC, this won't do it. :)
Add photograph to your favorites
Add photographer to your favorites
