There is nothing wrong with staging a photo. On the contrary: you put thought into it, you had an idea, and you executed it consistently and with sensitivity. That is a creative process—far more than a snapshot, which is largely a matter of chance.
I absolutely love this entry! It’s a perfect composition. Love the DOF and your concept and the connection you share with your son. Beautiful work of art! Congratulations.
Your photography skills are 2nd (3rd!) to none. Your entry is made even more emotive by the personal nature of the composition as stated in your description. Congrats on the well deserved ribbon.
Well thought out composition for the challenge with nice lighting and color. Something I truly love about this and your work is the natural unedited look of all your images. Beautiful work, Congratulations!
congratulations congratulations on the ribbon .. !!! ..
when i voted i hadn't seen all your competition .. but even when i had this turned out to be my absolute favourite ..
and my only vote of 10 ..
and who cares about it being staged .. its the resulting image that counts far more in this image ..xx..
my fav so far ..
absolutely loving that shallow dof ..
the clear notes on the page and the guitar in the background..
it's a wonderful image and perfect for the challenge .. 10 .. :)