DPChallenge: A Digital Photography Contest You are not logged in. (log in or register) 
 

DPChallenge Forums >> Current Challenge >> Chaos comments
Pages:  
Showing posts 1 - 21 of 21, (reverse)
AuthorThread
 04/11/2004 11:07:38 PM · #1
I just read my profile stats and found that I have received an average of about 20 comments per challenge - which I think is pretty high. Maybe that's why I'm so disappointed in only having 3 for my chaos entry! I also saw that I've left more than 4x's the number of comments I have recieved - and that's not including the current challenge where I commented on all of them. The entry was also one that I think is my second favorite of all my entries, yet I guess it just hasn't stuck a chord with the voters.

Someone said the votes are more important than the comments, but I disagree. Especially when it's a photo that I particularly like and maybe I'm not impartial enough to figure out the flaws. Oh well...it's almost over and maybe I'll get some more comments later.
 04/11/2004 11:15:33 PM · #2
Maybe your photo is so good and we are left speechless?
 04/11/2004 11:20:13 PM · #3
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Maybe your photo is so good and we are left speechless?


lol! That's it! (but it's only scoring a 5, so if I just ignore the votes, I can keep dreaming!)
 04/11/2004 11:23:53 PM · #4
If the score is between 4.5-5.2 photos don't get many comments!
 04/11/2004 11:28:44 PM · #5
Actually, you were one who did leave one of my three comments and I will have a question for you when the challenge is over.
 04/11/2004 11:29:36 PM · #6
Originally posted by jpochard:
Actually, you were one who did leave one of my three comments and I will have a question for you when the challenge is over.

Oh ,no! Am I in trouble again?
Let's smoke a peace pipe !

Message edited by author 2004-04-11 23:30:22.
 04/11/2004 11:33:55 PM · #7
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Originally posted by jpochard:
Actually, you were one who did leave one of my three comments and I will have a question for you when the challenge is over.

Oh ,no! Am I in trouble again?


Again? You make a habit of getting into trouble??? Virtual votes just aren't worth causing trouble for so you have no worry from me. I'm just curious about your comment.
 04/12/2004 12:07:43 AM · #8
Okay...here's my question.

Here's your comment on my entry:

"This is photo of someone's art? If yes you got 1 ."

Does this mean you scored me a "1" thinking that I took a picture of a painting or something? If you don't like the photo at all, that's cool, but I want to know if you gave it the benefit of the doubt.

I think it does almost look like a painting, but it is a photo taken at an Easter Play. Your comment is why I decided maybe I should have it validated. Thanks for the comment though...I do appreciate that you took the time to consider the shot. Here's my entry:

My entry
 04/12/2004 12:14:25 AM · #9
Wow. That shot was great. I gave it a 7. I also wondered if it was a photo of preexisting art. I gave it the benefit of the doubt while voting but I agree that validating may have helped. I can't believe you only got 3 comments (although I shouldn't talk since I didn't comment on it. Don't have that much free time lately.) Congratulations on an excellent photograph.
 04/12/2004 12:16:50 AM · #10
Originally posted by jpochard:
Okay...here's my question.

Here's your comment on my entry:

"This is photo of someone's art? If yes you got 1 ."

Does this mean you scored me a "1" thinking that I took a picture of a painting or something? If you don't like the photo at all, that's cool, but I want to know if you gave it the benefit of the doubt.

I think it does almost look like a painting, but it is a photo taken at an Easter Play. Your comment is why I decided maybe I should have it validated. Thanks for the comment though...I do appreciate that you took the time to consider the shot. Here's my entry:

My entry

It does look like someone's painting,maybe because of the sharpening done?.You could PM me and say no it isn't an art!
 04/12/2004 12:19:52 AM · #11
It so clear that its a play!
 04/12/2004 12:22:53 AM · #12
Originally posted by pitsaman:
It does look like someone's painting,maybe because of the sharpening done?.You could PM me and say no it isn't an art!


I have read through a lot of your comments and it does seem that you make a lot of assumptions. You made a bad assumption on her last photo also ;)
 04/12/2004 12:23:47 AM · #13
Well, I had already decided to not pm anyone during voting anymore. After all, it's really just not worth aggravating anyone.

So I'm assuming ,then, that your low score was made on your thought that this was a painting, and not strictly based on not liking the photo at all? One vote really doesn't matter, but if I'm correct and that is the case, maybe in the future it would be more fair to ask for a validation and reserve your vote until proof is provided....or, as the rules state, vote as if is it legal until proven otherwise.

Just a thought. I like the photo alot, but that's based on my own beliefs and the fact that it did turn out the way I had hoped.

On to the next challenge....
 04/12/2004 12:26:36 AM · #14
Well,drama play is still someone's art and as far I know cameras are prohibited in most of the theatres in Chicago !

At least I was honest to tell you why I'm doing that ,you have other 1 and twos without any explanation!

Message edited by author 2004-04-12 00:36:22.
 04/12/2004 12:31:16 AM · #15
Originally posted by jmsetzler:
Originally posted by pitsaman:
It does look like someone's painting,maybe because of the sharpening done?.You could PM me and say no it isn't an art!


I have read through a lot of your comments and it does seem that you make a lot of assumptions. You made a bad assumption on her last photo also ;)


So ,you don't like me any more?
 04/12/2004 01:52:41 AM · #16
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Well,drama play is still someone's art


Kosta I must be missing your point. You have entered pictures of musicians playing instruments into challenges. You have entered images of buildings, fountains, and objects that were not your creation. What exactly is it about someone who takes pictures of a play or painting that you object?
 04/12/2004 01:59:03 AM · #17
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Originally posted by jmsetzler:
Originally posted by pitsaman:
It does look like someone's painting,maybe because of the sharpening done?.You could PM me and say no it isn't an art!


I have read through a lot of your comments and it does seem that you make a lot of assumptions. You made a bad assumption on her last photo also ;)


So ,you don't like me any more?


I do like you. I just can't take you seriously :)

04/12/2004 02:05:17 AM · #18
Honestly,I was thinking ,it looked to me as a photo of a painting ,and my comment was also a question to her !
She could PM me to tell me that was not that and I would look at again!

Appears that since I started commenting everyone start taking on me here ! :-)
You don't have to take it seriously John,take it or leave it,not all your comments are perfect either!
 04/12/2004 02:16:08 AM · #19
Garrywhite makes a good point. I think I want to go back and revote on the postcards challenge. You didn't design those buildings and fountain did you? It's too bad, you deserve a 1.

Originally posted by garrywhite2:
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Well,drama play is still someone's art


Kosta I must be missing your point. You have entered pictures of musicians playing instruments into challenges. You have entered images of buildings, fountains, and objects that were not your creation. What exactly is it about someone who takes pictures of a play or painting that you object?
04/12/2004 02:13:53 PM · #20
Kosta the more I read this thread the more confusing it appears.

Just over a week ago you authored a thread recommending to make commenting during challenges anonymous.

Originally posted by pitsaman:
I decided to comment on 100 ++ photos today and guess what ?!
Despite the honest and constructive suggestions ( what I see) or how should be better IMHO,my mail box got bombarded by angry e-mails from dear members that maybe I need glasses or I'm too harsh!
Well,either the comments should be anonymus or members can choose no one should dare commenting on their photos!
I will keep commenting because is lot of fun ! :-)


If Judy were to PM you during the challenge it appears that you would be unhappy. If she PM'd you after the challenge, your second look would be of no value.

Even if Judy's photo had been that of a painting, I beg to understand your criteria in the differnce between her photographing someone elses art, with that of photographs you have taken of others art.

I don't want to keep hammering on this, you're a great photographer and I do value your opinion.

Message edited by author 2004-04-12 14:14:37.
 04/12/2004 02:52:57 PM · #21
Originally posted by pitsaman:
Honestly,I was thinking ,it looked to me as a photo of a painting ,and my comment was also a question to her !
She could PM me to tell me that was not that and I would look at again!



I was wondering why you didn't ask for a DQ and vote as if the shot was not a photo of a painting (or wait until it was validated)?
Pages:  
Current Server Time: 09/06/2025 02:50:45 AM

Please log in or register to post to the forums.


Home - Challenges - Community - League - Photos - Cameras - Lenses - Learn - Help - Terms of Use - Privacy - Top ^
DPChallenge, and website content and design, Copyright © 2001-2025 Challenging Technologies, LLC.
All digital photo copyrights belong to the photographers and may not be used without permission.
Current Server Time: 09/06/2025 02:50:45 AM EDT.