Bubbles...Bubbles...Bubbles
by Cooz

Comment:
Interesting concept and the deep purple and greens that are not overdone works well.

The background should have noise reduction applied to it and there are a number of hots spots reflected in the bubbles that are distracting. You might consider cloning out the tiny bubbles on the right that have no real definition and do not add much to the composition.

Rocking prism hologram
by graphicfunk

Comment:
Unique idea put together well in the photograph. Gives the viewer plenty to relate to and think about even if they are not into rock and rol music. Composed well.

The area around the bealtline of the guitarist is slightly overexposed and should be darken just a little bit.

Nice idea that should be favored by reviewers.

Cinderellas' Sisters
by kiwinick

Comment:
Nice concept, composition and colors work well. Good solid background that balance well against the birght colors. Reviewer will likely feel this meets the challenge. Very appealing image that should score well.

Be Careful Now Or The Rose Fairy Will Get You
by flip89

Comment:
Good idea for a fantasy world. A garden scene works and the idea of fairy and child is good. Composition and framing generally OK.

There are some areas where this could be improved. The general image technical quality is not particularly high and focus is soft. It appears the contrast is not correct and that a black point should be set. The direct sunlight is harsh, particualrly on the left side of the fairy character.

You might have considered having the fairy hold the broad leaf on the long stem over the child to convey a sense that the child is undergoing an enchanted spell. It might be good to have her attention directed toward the fairy character. In this pose she appears disinterested.

Juxtaposition
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
Nice composition, good colors and good general image technical quality. It does not have overexposed areas, applies good the rule of thirds well with the modern structure and the dramatic clouds add interest to the composition.

You might consider using light dodging to slightly brighten the far left side of the frame on the darkened portion of the building to keep it from drawing attention away ffrom the rest of the image.

Good image. Should get a decent score.

Thumbelina's Garden
by LucidLotus

Comment:
Nice B&W. Sprouts make a curious surrealistic world that works well for this challenge. Exposure is good. Full range of tones.

The white objects in a line are mostly out of focus draw but strongly draw attention. What they are and their purpose is unknown and are major distractions. It could be legitimately argued that in a fantasy world you won;t understand all things, but viewers will not buy that with those objects and it will hurt the overal score of this image. There is background some noise that should be removed.

The world below
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
Great perspective and good color. Framing is nice. Appears that horizon is level.

A view from this perspective will probably work for most voters as meeting the challenge. For some, of course, it will not. It is a creative approach to the challenge.

On the technical side focus seems on the soft side and detail gets lost.

Where the Purple People Eaters Live
by Shannon

Comment:
Natural framing is good. Bridge angle and covered wood creates a tranquil scene.

Unfortunately, this is a good example of a perfectly good image being destroyed by an attempt to meet a challenge. Color is artificial and wrong, image has excessive noise and image general quality and clarity is very poor. All this will contribute to a very low score. Chalk this one up as a learning experience.

Space Travel
by BrianR

Comment:
Curious metal abstract. Image quality and clarity is decent. Composition is OK.

This will leave some viewers with unanswered questions. The main thing will be they will wonder what that other part, besides the sky, that is reflected in the "space vehicle". Because it is to hard to figure out they may be a little frustrated and vote this composition a little lower as a result.

Starman
by sher

Comment:
Nice bokeh and the translucent look makes for a very appealing composition. Good composition and image quality. There are a number of alien themed images and reviewers having seen them could affect your score. The left shoulder and arm of the alien is overexposed and should be toned down a bit to keep them from being an image distraction.