Flame
by Rooster

Comment:
This is the only picture that meets the challenge 100% and makes sence. I guess it need some brain power to undersatnd what you did and a whole lot more to create such a photo.
great work.

Beary Nice
by Tammer

Comment:
This is good 10

Flame
by Rooster

Comment:
Now this is what it is all about. 10

Silenced
by lovethelight

Comment:
lovethelight said: "ps. I was wondering if the people who gave me 1s and 2s could tell me what it is they didn't like about it, because I have gotten a lot of positive feedback on this but would like to hear some negative feedback"

Your photo is technically good; but as you may appreciate, sometimes mere taste is a decisive factor in weighing a photos score; in a photo such as yours 1,2,3,4 even 5 represent the same attitude towards this type of photography. This does not necessarily reflect my exact opinion on such photos, but it is a response I felt you are entitled to.

Congratulations on the ribbon

Tareq

Message edited by author 2008-01-08 02:32:41.

Between a Sharp Rock and a Soft Place: Lizard Head Rock, Rye
by hotpasta

Comment:
10. One good photo. I enjoyed it.

Moonshadow
by pointandshoot

Comment:
Is this who I think it is!! great shot 10

Little House On The Prairie
by good_ham

Comment:
wow 10 such a neat beautiful take

Rememberance of Times Long Forgotten
by Rosacalaca

Comment:
excellent. is it whom i think it is? 10

Phrenology Head with Hair Brush
by De Sousa

Comment:
Great shot. I knew it was you. Gave it a 10.

Playmates
by alanfreed

Comment:

Originally posted by L2: Technicals here are well met with regard to exposure, composition, focus, etc. I don't mean to hurt your feelings, but this really seems like a standard portrait that you have to know the person to really like the image. There's no story - the girl and the cat aren't interacting -- there's no true personality captured or anything that makes me wish I was a) at the scene or b) knew the people in it. Technically though, you got it spot-on. Artistic merit - although pleasing, it's rather ordinary.

Do not listen to what L2 said above. I loved the cat and the girl because of the photo. I did not have to know them to like them. Great picture. and much under rated.

Message edited by author 2007-12-10 02:08:07.