Long Gone
by DefyTime

Comment:
great comp, great light, excellent texture, great color, the stars seem to be hung from the branchs of the tree, love the bg,

Last man leaving
by arpita

Comment:
Honestly, I am having trouble seeing desolation. In other words is it half full, or half empty. I can not tell. So, I'll give it to ya.

An amazing image. Excellent comp, excellent movement, excellent lines, blacks a bit too deep, and whites barely in because of this technicallity not perfect, minimalistic feel, great lighting, excellent texture, maybe a bit soft on the right hand shadowed area but not disturbingly,

The Great Expectation
by Photopromo

Comment:
Hera,

I can see great things comming from you. This DQ should only be viewed as a minor setback.

I would think the next time you leave behind any submissions in the future, that you have a plan to qualify future requests from SC.

Good luck in the future.

dye ing sun (De Sol Ation)
by B74A

Comment:
not convincing as destitute.

comp needs work, nice lines, duotone interesting, power lines distracting, light poles distracting, blacks a bit too deep, whites not there, light could be better, dof ok but a bit blurred in bg.

"Will Work 4 Challenge Points!"
by 777STAN

Comment:
A bit humorous, but not very convincing as destitute.

comp nice, good movement, color flat and over bright, blacks not bad, whites blown, ok texture, sharp enough, light flat,

Desolation
by cp5140

Comment:
The first thing that strikes me about this image is that it is way too dark.

comp ok, blacks too deep, whites just not there. In a b&w pix, to be convincing, you need to have texture in your pure blacks and pure whites. Overall, it is hard for me to give a proper critique on the lighting, dof and texture due to the underexposed image.

Always take the time to experiment with exposure even if it takes a couple of days to get it right.

These challenges are not a race to see who can upload an image first, but to see who has a handle on their forethought, and settings of the machine.

Watching the Fun
by bjallen

Comment:


Image is ok could be better, comp ok, angle interesting, color nice, dof ok, light nice

Who did it?
by mssnare

Comment:
Sorry, but I am not convinced of Desolation.

Definitions of desolation on the Web:

*devastation: the state of being decayed or destroyed
*bleakness: a bleak and desolate atmosphere; "the nakedness of the landscape"
*forlornness: sadness resulting from being forsaken or abandoned
*devastation: an event that results in total destruction

Extinguished!
by AzCKelly

Comment:
Sorry, but I am not convinced of Desolation.

Definitions of desolation on the Web:

*devastation: the state of being decayed or destroyed
*bleakness: a bleak and desolate atmosphere; "the nakedness of the landscape"
*forlornness: sadness resulting from being forsaken or abandoned
*devastation: an event that results in total destruction

Pinnacle Overlook
by PhotoTess

Comment:
Sorry, but I am not convinced of Desolation.

Nice comp, nice dof, blacks too deep, whites ok, nice light, minimalistic, nice movement, I get a feel of freedom and openness rather than destitute.