ArchiSquares
by Dallas_TX

Comment:
Cool picture. It would be better if it were vertical with respect to the frame. I don't think those are exact square either, but I'm not that hardcore like some of the people are for this challenge. Close enough for me. - Inspzil

Yellow & Green
by svital

Comment:
Nice sharp photo. Nice bright colors also. Good job - Inspzil

Where square people live.
by Harz_Joerg

Comment:
The crop is a little too tight for my taste. I also think it needs a little more contrast. Not a bad photo and I do think that monochrome is well suited for this pic - Inspzil

Square Shim
by GeneralE

Comment:
Good use of colored light on this one. Well taken photo - Inspzil

Squares and Sky
by bil99

Comment:
Looks like a good desktop wallpaper pattern, but not much in terms of artistic photography. sorry - Inspzil

Colorful Squares
by ed728

Comment:
I would've concentrated more on the pencils. The cube adds nothing to this pic IMO. THe gradient pencils are enough for me - Inspzil

Game Squares
by Artifacts

Comment:
Too much stuff. More stuff doesn't make it more better. I appreciate what you are trying to do, but it doesn't really work for me - inspzil

The last piece
by dodobird

Comment:
Good solid image. I love the idea. Nice colors and well taken. A little flat, but the framing is good - Inspzil

Midnight Square
by fsieradzki

Comment:
Good idea, Great photo. Very well taken indeed. The simplicity is good, not too simple. Seems to be a problem this week, oversimplifying - Inspzil

...Which Way?
by catpixel

Comment:
Critique Club by Inspzil

Composition - I like the composition of this photo to some degree. It isn't really weak nor really powerful either way. The post not being vertical bugs me a little. The background is dark and red and perfect for making the sign stand off the page. The foreground is pretty bright and very clear. I think the lighting works for the foreground. I think the few scratches on the sign where it was presumably hit give it a little character.

Photography - Well lit and exposed I think. DOF is not really an issue here and the photo is clear.

Post processing - I think this photo would be a candidate for radical transformations if it were mine. Maybe not for the challenge so much, but with a pretty basic one-subject relatively colorless shot, it might be time to have some fun. It looks like there may be a little jpeg artifacts floating around, but generally is pretty good and sharp.

Overall - This is a well taken photo. I'm not real wild about the composition though. The bend in the sign is enough to make it a little unique, but I think it needs something else. It is very close to being a really great picture. - Inspzil