A Long and 'Rinding' Road
by chrisab

Comment:
Nice shot and nice colors. I like a lot the contrast blue/yellow and the green fits perfectly. I like as well the 'road' is vanishing in the background of the picture. Nothing to say about the DOF, perfect to my taste. Just maybe the picture is a little 'cold' but .... very nice shot. 7. Lionel

Dreaming of me...
by fsieradzki

Comment:
ok ... I do not know what you're going to get. I like the picture and the grain in the picture. I think the light part is a little too much light, it should be there .. but just a little less. And to me it does not 'meet' the spirit of the challenge. This week 7, and other week probably a 9 or a 10. -1 or the light and -2 for the challenge. Overall 7. Very nice shot, be proud of that one. Lionelm

Penn Station, NYC, 8.30.02, WTC memorial
by mscott821

Comment:
I like the shot, the colors, its 'documentary' aspect but does not meet the spirit of a 'candid moment' to me, what is happening that makes it candid ?. Another Week 6 or 7. This week 4

Tropical Commute
by myqyl

Comment:
Nice shot but to me it does not meet the 'spirit' of the challenge. 7 an other week, 5 this week.

Eye Contact
by hokie

Comment:
Very nice shot and 'audacious' composition and framing. Challenge : not sure, benefit of the doubt. 7 good luck

HOT Summer Day...
by chakkobbo

Comment:
Nice candid shot. Would have benefit of having the subject more separated from the back ground. 6

Keeping the Water Company
by karmat

Comment:
Nice shot. THe framing could have been better I think. Nice exposure and color. Meet the challenge. 6

Holding my bag woulda killed you?
by annelizabeth

Comment:
Nice composition, angle, exposure and I like the litle 'movement' in the arms. I cannot say I would like to frame the picture, it does not 'appeeal' to me that much but for this challenge, this is very good.. Maybe a little too 'centered' ... but nice shot. 7. Lionel

Picnic
by GinaRothfels

Comment:
I like your picture. Nothing to say, good control of the exposure and DOF (I like the different 'plans'). 7. Lionel

For Rent: Desperate
by Jak

Comment:
Great shot, I have been reading you comments last week I think so .... I guess this one is not the 'first one'. i like the picture , but you are going to have 'biased' comments becasue people reading the forum whould know the background .... I think it should not have been talked in the forums before.
I am a little bothered bby the 'background' on the far right of the picture, but not it does not distract too much.
BUT I like the picture a lot. 7 currently, might be back later for a 8. Good luck