fog settles in
by ErinM

Comment:
Beautiful composition!

Royal Canadian Goose
by MaryO

Comment:
Beautiful sunset. Since the goose is the subject, I'd love to see him a bit more clearly ... perhaps with some processing or a fill flash.

Winter's Face
by Balko

Comment:
This makes me feel like I'm underwater. This is definitely an image that only gets better the more you look at it. It's dynamic and got a great 3D feeling to it. Nice work!

...On The Pond
by 777STAN

Comment:
What a perfectly still day this must have been! There's a bit too much going on I think, but you certainly have met the challenge. This might be a nice texture overlay.

ocular reflex
by shamer

Comment:
ewww, I do wonder what this is. It's definitely wonderful image quality and beautiful tones.

emit eht s'tahw
by jonfrommk

Comment:
Good title :-) This would be really eye-catching if the white part on the right were cropped out. Hope you don't mind my input, but I guess you don't if you've entered a challenge. I think the image quality is excellent, but it might benefit from a bit of increased saturation and contrast in the reflection. Good luck in the challenge!

Old Salmon Falls Bridge
by jdannels

Comment:
For me this image has everything going for it except for the angle of the bridge. It seems so separate from that lonely tree (perhaps that's what you're going for). I wonder how it would look if the view were from about ten steps to the right, so the bridge appeared to go much nearer the tree. I like the silky sky and the browns in the bridge reflection.

Knowledge Portal
by Donna21

Comment:
Oooh! I like how one has to look closely in the window to see the books reflected with the venetian blind background. I bet other people give you the same comment, but I will say it too: The plywood on the right draws my eye right over to that side, away from the books. I bet this could be a point or more higher if the crop showed only the dark wood frame of the door or window. I like the patterns made from the blinds and perpendicular books.

early light
by whiterook

Comment:
Well this fits the challenge as far as "reflective surface" goes, but I think the image quality is suffering. A polarizing filter would eliminate the strong white on the water, but since that is itself a reflection, maybe that's what you're going for! The parts around the green covered rocks seem a little oversharpened. The positive for me is that it meets the challenge and it's a pretty good composition. I like the way the shoreline curve echoes the curve from the foreground sand.

Ode to Harold
by hyperfocal

Comment:
Even though I can never, ever, ever get this perfect of a capture of milk or water drops, I'm going to be brave and give a bit of criticism ... hope you don't mind. For me, the light is just too harsh. It's an amazingly perfect drop shot though ... I just wish it could've been with much softer light.