Quiet Reflection - No Mirror
by Simms

Comment:
Acedâ€Â¦ Can't fault thisâ€Â¦ Lighting is dramatic. I can't quite see how you got the appearance of the double candle flame on the left side of the shot, possibly because there is glass in the frame, but however you did it, it's the icing on an already mouth watering cakeâ€Â¦ Fantastic inventiveness and superb shooting (10)

Heaven on Earth
by micalaurr

Comment:
Magicâ€Â¦ Love itâ€Â¦ Only moan; I would have liked to see the top of the sphere (bubble? If it is, that must have been a tough shot to get), apart from that small, almost pedantic, pathetic little point, I think it's a great shotâ€Â¦ (9)

Ready to Race a Semi
by alanfreed

Comment:
First class composition, first class photographyâ€Â¦ (10)

Umm.. I can't think of one
by pattonx

Comment:
This is a great shot with one small – in my opinion – element that lets it down. The rock at the bottom of picture draws you away, a bit like looking at the finger rather than to where it is pointing. Crop that out and I think it would be a lot closer to the big Oooh factor. Other than that, I think it's a praiseworthy effort (7)

One for all, all for one
by Azrifel

Comment:
I really like the idea and the shot itself isn't bad; I just think a splash of colour to offset the power of the green would have added balance to the shotâ€Â¦ (7)

Floating Flame
by bayu

Comment:
Great shot, but the people in the picture spoil it quite a bit. I think this is because they break the dramatic diagonal symmetrical pattern within the shot and draw the eye away from the picture as a whole. This is a small point, but it stops a great picture from being an awesome shotâ€Â¦ (7)

10 PINS
by clicker

Comment:
Pinball – wizard shot :o) Love it, great shot – I presume this shot is somehow related to the other pinball shot (just curious) – I like this shot (only slightly) better than the other, mainly because the symmetry adds to the overall compositionâ€Â¦ (10)

Four Eyes
by vtruan

Comment:
I like the idea – I love frogsâ€Â¦ For me, the composition of the shot is a little too central; I'd have been temped to treat a shot like this in much the same way as the negative space challenge and used the background to focus attention onto Froggy. Maybe, zoom out a few feet and place Froggy in the top right third of the image. Hope that doesn't sound too pedantic, good luck, and hey, it's a not a bad shot anywayâ€Â¦ (7)

Life Saver
by DCThiessen

Comment:
I'm sure I have seen this shot on PhotoSIGâ€Â¦ I thought it was superb then, and I think it's superb nowâ€Â¦ (10)

Inside the Dew Drop
by mcrael

Comment:
Love the colours; I think the biggest plus is the fact you haven't tried to make sense of what is reflected in the drop; this is a classic 'less is best' shot that really works. Awesomeâ€Â¦ (10)