Eyes by librodo
by chsmith

Comment:
Sorry, not trying to offend you but this doesn´t even come close to the original, the only thing I see similar is a girl and a cloth around her head. The composition, post processing, expression on the girl and especially the lighting are MUCH better in his shot. This is hardly bad though, you just picked a really hard shot to imitate and I think I am being overly hard on you for that reason. I ended up giving this a 5.

Tulip Trio Tribute / Blue - Banmorn 1/26/2005 - 1/27/2005
by barndog

Comment:
While I liked the lighting on his shot better this is far from bad, I like the pristine sharp look of this.

Beautiful Garden and a Beer = Comfort
by temba

Comment:
Needs better focus, the beer can is very fuzzy and could definately be sharper. Nice DOF though, like that part.

Wading into eternity "graphicfunk tribute"
by Travis99

Comment:
His shot was just composed and lit better, you just barely cut off the elbows and then leave so much space up above but this is pretty good, got a 6 from me.

Rise and Shine
by Tej

Comment:
This is pretty cool, been done to death ofcourse but this image simply works, a combination of the composition, lighting and DOF along with the colouring simply appeals to me. Nice job, got an 8 from me.

Tribute to Sonifo's "Dainty Gem"
by manic35

Comment:
I really liked Sonifos composition much better, this is not bad at all but the composition is a little too cramped for my taste. Good job on the lighting though.

A bad attempt on Rackats Free Study shot
by TrollMan

Comment:
Not bad really but the top of the drop would have to be as pristine as the lower part for me to really dig this shot. It just needs better clarity but like I said, not bad at all.

the bar at the end of the universe
by ursula

Comment:
Pretty cool backround, without it this would just be sligtly above average. 8 from me.

Original 7.557. Imitation 3.555. In joebar's pocket : 4.002
by kashi

Comment:
Sorry but shots like this need to be pristine and sharp to work and this isn´t even close so I threw you a 4.

The Preys Perspective Unusual Viewpoint Challenge
by Ristyz

Comment:
Pretty good job on the lighting, it makes this shot work, I love the shadow over the right part of the face.