IFBB Boxer
by AlexSaberi

Comment:
Way to go Alex, I have seen better stuff from you but definately worthy, didn´t know you boxed or used to box :)

Photographer
by Zoomdak

Comment:
I know I am busting your balls with this location but that´s just partly cause I am jealous :) Congrats!

Bedtime Stories
by jrdawson

Comment:
This one I like. Great texture and exposure and environment. Only thing I really dislike is the addition of BOTH vignettign and a frame, I think that´s a bit redundant and would have preferred this entry with only either but still one of the effects. Anyway, one of the best in the challenge as far as I am concerned, gave it an 8.

Stormy Earth
by LevT

Comment:
Well certainly meet´s the challenge but I kindof feel like I am looking at a picture of really nothing since there is no main subject in the photo. Still nice and got a 6 but just lacks a place for my eyes to stop.

Bubble Trouble
by Man_Called_Horse

Comment:
Well this is a cool concept but could stand to be better executed technically, specifically the fact that the girl is out of focus and has such wierd skintones and wierd texture in the face (wich I blame on the post processing, I think the girl is very cute of course). I really like the idea and the distortion on the boy makes it really seem like he´s trapped in there. Maybe some soap reflection on his bubble would perfect the illusion (I mean blue oilish reflection like is on her bubble) 6 from me.

In Search of Food
by bryantbus

Comment:
This kindof makes me think of Cutter´s Triptych ribbon. Anyway, a nice shot and pretty well captured, think I would have liked it better if the eagle had been in the upper right corner and not the left and I personally may even have gone so far as to move it since that´s allowed in the ruleset but I respect that you didn´t. A small halo around the bird though that bothers me, you sure your monitor isn´t a little too bright? Anyway, great shot, 7 from me.

Obstruction
by see

Comment:
A nice shot but not quite enough for me to give a higher score than 6, just lacks that certain "wow" factor for me personally but absolutely nothing wrong with it.

Cold and frosty
by RUEDISCHMUTZ

Comment:
A bit on the flat side contrast wise for my taste but nothing that´s really bothering me. I do like the composition but have a feeling it would have been better if you had been standing on the left side of that trail, having it begin in thelower right corner and go up in the hills like it does here. Did you take any shot´s like that? Would like to see the comparision at least. 6 from me.

Circle of Hope
by banmorn

Comment:
An ok shot, fit´s the challenge certainly but I have a hard time connecting to the subject without having a face there somewhere.

Martian Moon
by Blackbox

Comment:
Well the ground looks beliavable as a moon, so does the rock but the sky on the other hand is too gray (as in not black) for it to be really believable. If I had done this image I would have gone out and taken star sky shot´s and used that as the sky, would have lead this image to be much more aesthetically pleasing. Also the blur on the rocks close to the horizon is also giving it away, this would have infinity focus if it were a real photograph from the moon or the floating rock would also be blurry. Nice effort, just needs better execution and your all set :)