Delicate & Lovely
by librodo

Comment:
Bang bang I was right ;) A very mesmerizing win.

Odor-Eaters???
by Nald

Comment:
Yeah timberlands have a tendency to do that. Mine does that too, it really sucks. Unless you capture it in a picture! Awfully creative I must say, one of the best in the challenge.

Missing you...
by miriam_mrb

Comment:
Very very cute idea but it could have been executed perfectly. A lower angle would get a better view of the dog and give it more of a realness and you shouldn't have to worry about the cluttered background ;) the lighting is position at the wrong place, plus it's too harsh, if it was a little bit more diffused that placment would not have been seen. But good working your model

BIRDS OF A FEATHER
by anthonyczaja

Comment:
Not bad this could be a great fashion shot, the lighting is awsome, the high contrast is great. The location is quite nice as well, I love that stony feel and the replace colour really works well with it. But it really doesn't go with your idea of "Birds of a feather"; because they have nothing alike, my suggestion would have been (if they are posing models that is) to find identical clothes and shoes for them and make them pose alike. Because like this it kind of seems out of there and random. But technically it's a great and original shot.

Red Boot
by painthorse

Comment:
There is a great setup as well as a great idea behind this shot, the only thing that's really annoying it the really harsh lighting which could have semi-fixed with curves or waited for a later hour.

Memento Mori
by mannjudit

Comment:
This may be one of the best pictures I've seen in a while, it just leaves the viewer wondering it really does, and the post-processing is marvelous as well... Of course the pole there is really misplaced but it really doesn't interfere the picture. This is a beautiful conceptual piece, left to the viewers interpretation, you just wonder, what are the shoes doing there? Did they have an owner that just jumped into the water? Or did they go there all by themselves...A 10 for a magnificent out of the box shot

Prayer
by asij

Comment:
This is perfect. I'm trying really hard to find something to give advice on but everything works out perfectly. The composition is nice, the tight framing right on spot. The grain gives a nice, sad and moody effect, that as Rob kind of prooved it, can't be without. The B&W is a nice choice, it's hard to image this picture in colour, I really do thing that would not have the same effect. And as for the cloud, above her head. I just have to say that that's wonderful, it's magnificently placed. Did you wait for it to go there? I mean it just leaves it so much to interpretation! For one thing you could say that it's the girls soul, flying off. or maybe the dead's soul flying past the praying girl. The wind blowing on the girl's hair is just a fabulous detail. This is perfect as it is and I can't keep myself from faving it.

Kenneth Cole, New York
by banmorn

Comment:
Looks like a window display, and as a window display I'm sure it gets lots of attention but as a photograph, well it's quite busy. The colours go really well together and the lighting is well executed too but like I said the papers just doesn't seem to belong in this picture. And I still stand beside my belief that this is a window display :P

My boots
by mariaksteinsson

Comment:
Very sexy, good lighting, exciting. The details are really nice, like the reflection of the booth on the floor, that's just marvelous, that alone could have made the pica success. The silver cross and the booth laces go well together and seem to complete the picture. I may be wrong but the fishnet stocking just don't seem to fit into the picture somehow, sure they're meant to be sexy, but they're too intrusive for my taste. But hey, that's just a minor detail in this very creative picture.

Ms. Vocalist of Animal Alpha Band
by terje

Comment:
This was my only ten in the challenge, deserved better. But hey 5 is still something right?