Wheel of Progress
by brassil

Comment:
Nicely taken photograph. It is very well composed. I find myself strangely drawn to it.

Smokestack
by aeli2468

Comment:
This is a very good picture for the challenge - it really has a great industrial feel to it. To me, the composition would have been improved by including more of the stack. Right now the crop puts the end of the stack at the half mark of the picture - if more of the stack were included so it ended at the top 1/3 it would have been more visually appealing.

Dancing Needles
by AlanBes

Comment:
This really does suit the challenge and has a great "industrial" feel to it. My eyes just keep wishing there was more in focus than one needle. If more was in focus it would be more visually appealing to me.

"I'm Takin' What They're Givin' 'Cuz I'm Working For A Livin'"
by rayg544

Comment:
Very nice composition!

dryer
by undieyatch

Comment:
This has a nice industrial feel to it. To me, it needs a bit more contrast and less of the blank stuff in the foreground. I really like the one lighted window - it gives a kind of Thomas Kincade "cottagey" feel to this industrial scene. It is very appealing.

cloud factory
by saintaugust

Comment:
This really does have a gritty, industrial feel to it. To me, the compostion would have been inproved if the stack would have been on the right third line rather than almost in the middle. Also, the wires look very jaggy - they could have been this way but it kind of looks like it comes from the compression in resizing.

Samoa Pulp Mill
by bryanbrazil

Comment:
Wow, this is lovely. You have made industrial look beautiful. The reflection in the water really adds to your picture. This should be one of the ribbons!

Industrial shore
by pacpinto

Comment:
Very nice picture for the challenge. I really like the feeling it gives me.

Ascension
by peete

Comment:
Very nice composition.

Against a blue sky
by ArpeggioAngel

Comment:
The stacks on the left look great but for some reason the stacks on the right have jaggies on the long sige. The border is also a bit wide and overwhelms the picture to some degree. It is a great picture for the challenge.