Magic Mountain by Thomas Mann
by MargaretNet

Comment:
Fantastic detail and a truly breathtaking capture.
on one hand i'm happy that i did not have to climb this high to get this image myself (terrified of heights), and that i'm able to see this view; on the other hand i'm terribly jealous that I cannot show this off to friends and family and say "look at this amazing image that I took".
definitely a favorite and a wishlist, this deserves to up on a wall (many walls, really).
a 10 from me.
i truly hope that this image was taken within the date range for the challenge as it would be an absolute shame if it wasn't

The Secret Garden
by giantmike

Comment:
i like the hinted trail, but don't know if i'm supposed to be looking at the trail from IN the garden, or the trail that Leads to the garden.
a 6 from me

Catch Her in the Rye
by IrvineJames

Comment:
overall a nice scene with good composition and just enough light on the model
a 7 from me

"Please Sir, I want some more"
by Shifty_Powers

Comment:
i'm really having a hard job judging this one.
the fact it's just the hands and bowl lend to the fact that it could be anybody, but the lack of 'more' leaves me feeling like it's me with my hands on the bowl, asking for more of the image.
an 8 is all you get, now go and be happy with it

Snow White
by PennyStreet

Comment:
oh, that wicked old witch and her apple....
LOOK OUT SNOW, PUT DOWN THE CAMERA!!!!
an 8 from me for this humorous take on the evil apple

Black Beauty
by jomari

Comment:
nothing major to say positive or negative, it's a very literal image which is what one would expect from that book.
a 6 from me

"A River Runs Through It" by Norman Maclean
by rjkstesch

Comment:
looks like a painting
good use of long (or multiple) exposure here in the water. i personally would perfer less on top of the image and bring the river up more in the frame
an 8 from me

Fanny Hill
by disassociation

Comment:
the look on the face just isn't working for me, it seems forced, while this type of pose should seem natural. it's the eyes mostly, they should be looking directly into lens to make a connection with the viewer, but here they are seemingly looking over my shoulder
a 6 from me

Damn Dust - The Grapes of Wrath
by Rmac

Comment:
the sneer make this image for me.
a 7 indeed

Charlotte's Web
by glad2badad

Comment:
i'm disappointed you couldn't train the spider to spin messages into it's web, unless those dots are actually morse code.
*checks*
it's rubbish, all it says over and over is "seven" when clearly this is undoubtedly an 8