Smoke
by van63

Comment:
Smoke indeed. But not that interesting. With so little context (trees on the bottom right) I'm left to wonder why the smoke is there and what dramatic event might be occurring to cause the smoke. I think a super wide angle lens with something relevant (like the fire causing the smoke :P ) in the foreground would have improved this shot.

Western Flyer
by RDEittreim

Comment:
I like the cropping work you've done here, but it does not save the rim from being overexposed by at least 2/3 of a stop. The harshness of midday sun can sometimes work to your advantage, but I wonder if some softer, overcast lighting would have been better. Your choice of background and is superb and begins to tell us a story about the bike and it's roots. Perhaps including the legs of a young boy dressed in 50s and conversion to black and white would bring out the rustic feeling of the image. Good effort.

Spectrum
by arsenal

Comment:
Pretty cool image. Without the "bubble", this would be mediocre. As it is, it's quite nice. I wonder what that dark patch in the upper right is though. I understand it couldn't be cropped out, but it's still a distraction. Imagine the bubble without the reflections...I think it would be slight improvement. Still, I give it an 8.

4 hours circle before sunset
by ingib

Comment:
Decent image of a very popular subject. The background is sufficiently blurry to keep my focus on the circular weed. The image does not have any serious technical faults, yet it does not appeal to me. Perhaps if there were a pair of lips in the frame, blowing the seeds to the wind. Something to spark my interest.

Duo Maxwell
by AmiYuy

Comment:
Not really seeing a circle, but I'll give you the benefit of doubt. The subject is interesting and has attitude, but the hat and the position of the hands seems unnatural. Also, taking an engaging photo of someone wearing dark sunglasses is difficult. Next time, perhaps try to incorporate something with similar style that allows us to see the eyes.

Crunchy Circles
by Minstrel

Comment:
Your white balance seems to be far too warm (orange), at least on my monitor. The perspective is a little odd and it seems you'd have done better to go either completely topdown or more of a severe angle. As it is, the angle creates a very "normal" perspective as though I were sitting there looking at the cereal. The background material is distrcting and has far too much detail. The spoon could be omitted to greater effect. Decent effort, though.

yinyang
by messerschmitt

Comment:
Simple, graphic and well-composed. Still, the image is tilted slightly to the left and is off-center just enough to be uncomfortable to the eye. I like the subtle shift in colors, though, and the texture of the painted molding. 6.

Simply elegant
by Pascal

Comment:
Very nice composition. I wonder if a little more light coming from the left wouldn't have helped the image though. It's a bit dark. Good luck!

Danger! Danger! Alert!
by mocabela

Comment:
Hmmm. I really like this! The composition is quite strong and you've managed to capture a closeup of a foot without it looking icky. Couple things:
- the sock impressions on the skin are visible, though not overly distracting.
- the dark material in upper right is distracting
- visible grain gets worse on the right side of the image, though again not too distracting...just noticeable

Good luck

War of the Tacks
by sofapez

Comment:
WTF? Did you setup a mini tack battle on your rear-end? Wow. Props for the um, idea, but it lacks a certain asthetic that keeps from looking in the opposite direction. I type this comment with my back to the keyboard.