Waiting for a Sunny Day
by alanfreed

Comment:
Composition7
Technical Aspects6
Appeal6
Creativity6
Rating6Autool

"look what I found"
by silver101

Comment:
Composition5
Technical Aspects6
Appeal6
Creativity5
Rating6Autool

Old Friends
by cameo

Comment:
A lot of the pictures have subdued lighting to emphasise the "old". Yours excells because the colors and black background enhance that effect. Good job! Autool

Jean Newhart, Antiques
by sjgleah

Comment:
Your picture suggesst something old but it misses the mark for me. The hanger for the sign might be old, and if it is I feel you should have worked your way in closer to make it your main focal point. In my opinion any way. Autool

Isn't dad too old for these toys?
by lcgleah

Comment:
Subject is near the edge on this challenge. It looks like the focus is a little soft. Autool

Old Man of the Forest
by bobgaither

Comment:
Pictures have been taken of these for as long as they have had cameras, so it is difficult to take a "new" picture of one. In that case the photographer must strive to take the best picture he/she can. I have no suggestions other than just think of how you could have done the picture to cause interest in the viewer. A difficult task at best. Good luck! Autool

We don't get many visitors anymore...
by mscott821

Comment:
This would have been great in the Corporate World thing. Good here too. The junk kind of overpowers the old for me though. A closer shot of the building would have been more powerful. Autool

Steamboat Willie
by BAMartin

Comment:
Even though you wanted them to look older with your lighting I think it would have been more powerful if you had used more light. Use indirect light to keep from getting unwanted glare. You probably tried moving them around, but the placement still doesn't look right to me. My problem is I don't know what would help. In my opinion, Autool

The Foundation of Life
by Ronin

Comment:
It looks like you done everything right to me. Good luck

Autool

Communication
by RedRuthann

Comment:
Great subject, but I think you need more light with aperature and speed adjustments to compensate. The subject will prove its age without the subdued lighting. In my opinion, Autool