Forgotten
by amsmyth

Comment by bayonic:
very very good.

Rural
by amsmyth

Comment by jpochard:
Hello from the Critique Club!

This is really a nice rural shot, and I think it's a strong connection to the idea for the challenge. It's a nice setting with some interesting features - the silos, hills in the background, the greeness of the area against the white buildings and greenhouses. They all work well together here, I think.

I agree with everyone else that the biggest change I would make to this shot is to adjust the rotation to correct the "tilt". I might also like to see the colors brightened up just a bit, but others may have a different opinion on that.

Cropping seems to be okay. I might also crop out a little more on the left hand side to bring the focus more on the main part of your scene.

It's an nice entry for this challenge. I hope this has been helpful!

Forgotten
by amsmyth

Comment by orussell:
Composition: Subject Placement, Cropping, Background 6
Technical: Focus, Exposure, Lighting, Processing 5
Appeal: Is it Interesting, Motivating, Etc. 6
How well does it meet the challenge: 7
Total Averaged Rating(Rounded) 6
Slightly oversharpened I think.

Abstract Found
by amsmyth

Comment by peecee:
I think a closer view would have been a better choice.

Abstract Found
by amsmyth

Comment by suemack:
love the idea

Abstract Found
by amsmyth

Comment by cpanaioti:
The cut wood has some nice texture. Move in, zoom in, take advantage of it. The trees in the background are distracting. 4

Abstract Found
by amsmyth

Comment by GinaRothfels:
I wish you'd got incloser.

Forgotten
by amsmyth

Comment by L1:
This is one of the only "rusted items out in a field" shots that I really like. The colors and tones really are interesting and the composition is good. A bit out of focus, but a good shot.

Forgotten
by amsmyth

Comment by oskar:
Brilliant - really old and great subject for the challenge

Forgotten
by amsmyth

Comment by Neil:
Very well seen and taken.
Other Comments:
Composition: would have been nice to get the edge of the wheel in on the left
Technical: seems to be some color noise (see the wagon color)