Eye contact
by Neat

Comment by tjbel05:
Seems like a very busy place at lunch time.

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by IreneM:
It's a beautiful image, Anita. Congrats on the red.

chained
by Neat

Comment by roz:
i'm surprised firstly that this didnt do better .. and secondly that it had no comments ..
so i will rectify the latter ..
i like this so much .. its dramatic and has impact ..
love the black and white treatment ..
and i dont find it boring at all .. ;)
in fact seeing it .. i wish i had got out of my comfort zone and done something .. anything .. for this challenge ..
and looking through all the entries just now has opened my eyes to the possibilities .. :)

Only the shell remains
by Neat

Comment by jerryc12:
It's easy for me to criticize because I wasn't there but this fantastic facade would look really great straight on rather than the angle you have taken. I know it may not have been possible.

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by jomari:
Congratulations on the red, Anita. I love this shot. I'm sure your friend will too. I agree with your definition of this. Sill or not it is still performing as a shelf.

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by Ammie:
I was torn between shelf and sill, gave it a compromised 7 in the end! Haha! Great work as always. Congrats too!

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by primabarbara:
With the bottles it has more shelf than window sill feel about it.
I liked the light, the grain and softness . Congrats!

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by Neat:

Originally posted by marnet: It looks that lack of Shelf did not harm it (I gave it a 5 for DNMC) Obviously, most people did not notice or mind, or simply did not comment. Congrats on the ribbon (mine was on 6.52 at 42 votes so the last 3 voters may have made the difference)

I can see that you would think it might not meet the challenge, but to me a shelf is something you place an item on, so I kind of did meet the challenge. I was in the 5's after day one, slowly climbed all week, mind you just 24hrs ago I was on 6.20, I had a few kind last minute voters.

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by MargaretNet:
It looks that lack of Shelf did not harm it (I gave it a 5 for DNMC)
Obviously, most people did not notice or mind, or simply did not comment.

Congrats on the ribbon
(mine was on 6.52 at 42 votes so the last 3 voters may have made the difference)

Window shelf
by Neat

Comment by jomari:
Beautiful shot. One of my ribbon picks. Actually, make that 10 and top two.