Fresh Homemade Bread
by melking

Comment:
I can smell the bread already and it is making me hungry. Very good shot and very good interpretation of the challenge. 10 for you.

Burn Out
by arnit

Comment:
This photo is very well done. I can smell the smoke already. I like it a lot. Good job.

Soar II
by shareinnc

Comment:
I really don't understand what is so surprising about this. If you could explain yourself I might be tempted to change my score.

What's up?
by sahko

Comment:
I love this photo and how did you manage to get the little guy to stay still for your shooting session. Excellent shot.

Look Out!
by vonautsch

Comment:
Maybe I'm brain challenged but I don't get this photo at all. Could you explain this please?

boo!
by ursula

Comment:
I'm sorry but this to me portrays two children playing. I see no surprised look nor do I see the intention of surprise.

Have I Got a Surprise for You!
by StevePax

Comment:
I don't understand this photo at all concerning the challenge.

Pop!
by ScantyNebula

Comment:
Great thought and good picture. My only thought is that I don't like the circle of light by the pin. If you would have tried to do this in natural light on your tripod I think it would have looked better. All in all though a very good depiction of the challenge and I'm sure it was hard to get that pin in the balloon before it actually did break. LOL --another good photo --a picture of the person holding the pin when the balloon did break.

Shocking Message
by oskar

Comment:
I love the idea and the portrayal. One question though -- if it is a woman leaving her husband for his father --why the man's wedding ring? From the ring I get the idea that it is one guy leaving another guy for the father. This in no way affected the outcome of the score I gave you. Just a personal thought. The picture and the idea behind it (which ever scenario one chooses to think) is great. Good luck!

Unexpected Birthday Surprise
by Coley

Comment:
I'm sure that some people find this more surprising than others. I also had this idea but dropped it for another one. You did it perfectly though and I applaud you for your effort. It is great. A 9 from me.