Desert Horse & Rider
by kvickrey

Comment:
The vignetting seems a bit heavy for my taste, and not sure if it is due to the vignette or sharpening, but a strange halo'ing effect is evident around some parts of the rider/horse, most noticeably above the horse's rear and at the forefront of its chest/front left leg.

Sports 3
by Katmystiry

Comment:
Great job on this one. Numbers, faces, and the action are all very evident in this one. I, too, rather like the lighting, especially since the white jerseys likely would have been totally blown out had the lighting been from the front.

IMG_4525.jpg
by Zippy

Comment:
One thing that may have been unavoidable considering the setup, is the background combined with her outfit. Since everything behind her is so dark, it makes her melt into the background. The timing is great though, especially how you not only got the ball striking the racquet but also got her "levitating" above the court.

#2 - Blokart
by hajeka

Comment:
Excellent job at panning. I assume that the red square object ahead of them is only a consequence of the panning itself, but it distracts me a little bit due to how vibrant it is in contrast to the sand.

_MG_1462.jpg
by jan_vdw

Comment:
I don't know a lot about Cricket, but I'm left wondering what exactly is going on in this photo other than the player running.

_MG_1068.jpg
by jan_vdw

Comment:
In addition to what others have said, I think that it would be nice to have the background slightly more blurred to help accentuate the subject more, but, of course, that likely was a hardware limitation.

IMG_4408.jpg
by Zippy

Comment:
I think the tightness works pretty well for this one, though a tad too tight to the extent that (as others have said) the racquet is chopped. The shot shows great tension, what with her taut arms and strained expression.

SMC-swimming-2008-043.jpg
by cryan

Comment:
Another shot with great timing and focus. You already addressed the noise in the other photo, really the only thing that I'm not a fan of on this is the last bit of hand being cut off; it seems like an unnatural "breaking point" for the shot. The waist seems more "natural" to me. And depending upon the original capture and if this hand chopping was due to cropping or the initial composition, you could move the face and eye to the lower right intersection of thirds to balance this out more left to right.

The Block
by Katmystiry

Comment:
I think this is the best angle to capture this from, because from this vantage point you can see not only the distance between the rusher and the QB, but also where the ball is going and the front of the quarterback. Background is only slightly distracting, and only because of the backlighting of the trees. As others have said, tighter framing on the rusher/QB duo would improve this as well.

SMC-swimming-2008-051.jpg
by cryan

Comment:
Great shot. The noise isn't that big of an issue to me, mostly because it is more noticeable in the background and not on the subject. The shutter speed is a nice compromise between stopping all the droplets in the air and still letting some motion into the photo. A tad bit of the elbow seems to be chopped off though.