Nude III challenge original shot
by DrJOnes

Comment:
I agree with you 100%. You can't always depend on the powers that be to understand why that strobe is not a major element.

Sunset on field
by letuananh

Comment:
Great photo... i hope the 'meet the challenge' mongers don't kill you... 10 from me.

Hot to the Touch
by JeB

Comment:
This photo doesn't really meet the challenge very well. The circles are implied and don't represent a key element in the composition, as described in the challenge. It's an interesting image, to some extent, but it's a bit abstract and won't extract much 'wow' from the voting public.

Big Brother is watching...
by burtct

Comment:
It's always helpful to read the rules since you checked the box that indicated that you had done so :) The idea here is good but the editing (which is illegal in this challenge) is rather poor.

Addendum: I shouldn't assume this is illegal. I did vote it as if it was legal. I just don't like the remnants of whatever editing was used. It looks too strange to me and I can't see or find purpose in those remnants.

Now THIS, Little Duck, is a Circle!
by khdoss

Comment:
Some people never get bored :)

Lawn Bowling
by RolandB

Comment:
Meets the challenge... interest level in the subject may be rather low. There is no particular hook in this photo to make me want to delve deeper...

A Natural Circle
by Jeileen

Comment:
Very nice concept... lacks focus though and there is no real reason that everything shouldn't be in focus in this photo as far as I can tell...

Double Span
by bongo

Comment:
Excellent detail and composition... nice subject isolation and smooth background...

Out of the Dark
by arnit

Comment:
This is excellent work. The exposure and detail both create a fascinating image. It's definitely one of the best photos in this challenge.

I think your border would be more appropriate if the white area was about 2 or 4 pixels wide rather than what you have here.

Head Games Singer
by pitsaman

Comment:
excellent intensity and nice high contrast b/w work...