You are never alone
by Dufus

Comment:
Good Points: A great shot on it's own right, nice lighting and great level horizon
Bad Points:bit to saturated. And although it won't effect my score, I think some DPC'ers will say it doesn't meet the challenge enough. (bah hunbugs) does to me though great shot. (would be more fitting in light challenge mind you)
Overall Score:7

H2O
by kiwiness

Comment:

Originally posted by kiwiness: If you are anywhere near here today, come on over the beer is on me. Thanx thanx thanx, I love this game :-)

Hell if that's an invite to New Zealand, I'm on my way! ;)

I am pretty tight with my 10's, but most of your pictures always seem to get it from me, which pleases me heaps. Your on a roll!

American Beauty
by grigrigirl

Comment:
Good Points:wow! what a pose! Fills the frame perfectly, love the grain (although many will prbably complain about it) and the desaturated look, exactly what I like in body shots.
Bad Points: Whilst ribs sticking out isn't nice - I knid of think it adds to the image, a bit kooki. The same goes for the creases in her neck. So I guess that's not really a bad point at all.
Overall Score: 10! (and looking forward to see who took it)

Traffic Islands
by Imagineer

Comment:
superb shot! Love the people in the middle, gives it such edge.

Cosmopolitan
by WILDBLUE

Comment:
nice to see someone finally using a dynamic angle. topmarks

Cappuccino Crème Brûlée
by Gordon

Comment:
Good Points:awsome focusing, good choice of apature, composition is spot on
Bad Points:woudl like to have seen more enphassis on actual cooking, but guess your legal being before ;)
Overall Score:9

Dijon Pork Chops and Fries
by alternarule

Comment:
Good Points:creative thinking with teh composition
Bad Points: sadly it doesn't work for me, if the plates were closer this would be much better I feel. Also the food on the fork doesn't look pretty
Overall Score:3

Greek salad with Avocado & Hallumi Cheese
by Apollo2077

Comment:
Good Points:nice idea with the different colors, like the way you have centred teh lemon.
Bad Points:way to brightly lit. A lot of detail has been lost as a result of that and the lemons are blown out.
Overall Score:4

Blueberry and Apple Muffins
by train

Comment:
Good Points:well composed, and a nice subject. Inclusion of flower is good idea. Good textures on the tablecloth.
Bad Points:slightly underlit with the white plate not being white enough. try using curves if you have photoshop. Also a bit more blue at the bottom, perhaps a bit too closley cropped.
Overall Score:7

Rice-Stuffed Cornish Hens
by Sonifo

Comment:
Good Points: At first I was thinking 3, too cluttered, but it kind of works I think, I would expect to see this kind of thing in an old cook book, a traditional one. Composed well, and great colors. Very seasonal
Bad Points:Perhaps slightly too much going on..and would have left out the china.
Final Score:8