Along the Fence Line
by timfythetoo

Comment:
Tim - Excellent use of leading lines and warm soft tones - This is an absolute keeper. I am very fond of this image, but I am not sure that the perspective here really hits you over the head (a good thing in this case!)

By the way, my wife loves this image as well - especially the colors and tones (she was looking over my shoulder and made me go back to this one...

the street
by AP

Comment:
I really like the image - but I wish the person in the image was all there. The ghosting doesn't work real well for me.

Curvy Reflection
by silverscreen

Comment:
I like the lines created by the building at lot- This one has a great deal of coolness to it. I almost think that reorienting the image so that the curve starts in the corner might help. The other thing that slightly affects this is some apparent oversharpening on the windows.

The reflection of the other building really screams to be emphasized more - i think wardmac had a good idea for recropping.

Daddy?
by levyj413

Comment:
Jeff- I like it. The noise works really well and I like the thumb sucking to add some nervousness and fear.

the last time
by chele

Comment:
Michele - Excellent image. Very stark and foreboding. You really need to go spend some time in the sun!!!

2406.jpg
by aliqui

Comment:
Michelle- I quite like the processing and heavy handed feel of the processing. It seems so remote and forlorn here. I am not sure about the crop on the left - I would like to see the sweep of the rocks all around (dark line seems to be cut off a bit as it comes from the top, down the left and then to the right). The tones really work for me, especially on the sand. The waves on the beach are an outstanding feature of the shot and i almost wish it where emphasized more (a closer crop on that as a second shot).

Not a "HUMMER" Accessory
by cyan

Comment:
a great stupid gift - i just wish the composition were a bit more interesting, maybe with the kazoo at an angle instead of horizontal. The focus also does not appear to be really sharp

Dust Mop Slippers - Already in the Trash
by laser

Comment:
Those are really cool! You should have sold them on ebay - they would have made you a load of money. I like the gift a lot - this gift has the potential to be the stupidest in the whole challenge - I just wish you had a shot with them actually one, possibly holding the label. The background in the trash really doesn't work for me- it distracts a lot and makes it less humorous.

A Sh1te Present!
by SteveJ

Comment:
That is one heck of a stupid present! I just wish the lighting were a whole lot better, the image was in sharp focus, and that it was a more interesting composition.

This wasn't on my list!
by Chappie23

Comment:
funny idea - but the background being so cluttered makes this come off too much of a snapshot