80 Years After Ansel Adams...
by smellyfish1002

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Well, I found it interesting that I got this image to critique via the critique club. It is going to be quite difficult to give a very objective critique since this was one of my two 10s in the challenge!

There is obviously something about this image that did not appeal to other voters in the same way it did to me because it only scored 5.9 and that I find to be somewhat perplexing. I wonder if it is the composition? Personally I think the composition is excellent. Or perhaps it's because of the lighting? It is quite unusual, but I find it works well, although I suppose there are quite a lot of shadows in the statue due to the flash.

I have a feeling this would also work well in black & white, although the colours are stunning in this version.

Sorry I can't be more help, but as I mentioned, I liked this one!

cieux déchirés
by Ecce_Signum

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Well, this is going to be difficult for me to critique under the circumstances, but as you have put it up for comments, I will give it a go. I personally like it very much, but I think you already knew that.

I was browsing through the highest LB scores section and noted that there are quite a few rather high scoring images with the LB. Perhaps people are starting to appreciate the blurry effects now.

As far as your score goes, I do think it was pretty respectable for a lensbaby image. I think possibly the burnt out highlights in the sky may have made the difference between 5.8 and 6, sorry I didn't think to mention it before! I'm not sure if that's a product of the lensbaby itself, or if it's come about by the b&w processing, but it did possibly impact the score.

Overall the moodiness created by the heavy sky really makes this image. I'm certain there are still a few people put off by the blur, but still a good performance from where I am sitting. Well done!

Deaths Grin
by Stephie3041

Comment:
Greetings from the Critique Club

Have to confess my first reaction to this was - ooh, gross. But that's only because of the decay and nothing to do with the photograph, so you got a strong reaction which is something. Interestingly you do not have any 1s.

It was an interesting interpretation of the challenge topic and perhaps a few voters didn't think it actually met the challenge.

I do think the composition probably hurts this quite a bit. I think it is framed too tightly and should probably have been taken at a wider angle to give some context.

The image itself is not really 100% in focus either. I think for this to work you would need to have shot it so the whole of the skull was in focus. The way it is now it looks like a mistake not intentional.

Just some things to consider for the next challenge.

The Sentinel
by Dr.Confuser

Comment:
You did a fabulous job with the tone mapping. I expected this to score a bit higher. :)

Reflection
by trevytrev

Comment:
I really love this image. In fact, it was one of my highest scores.

After the Langdale storm
by pffree

Comment:
Paul congrats on a great score. I can feel the dampness. Must have been extremely soggy!

cieux déchirés
by Ecce_Signum

Comment:
It is hard to imagine that this is summer. I still like it and think it's a pretty cool LB image.

Walking Down
by smyk

Comment:
Love this one. In fact it was one of my top picks. I expected it to score a lot higher

The lady with the dog
by LevT

Comment:
Didn't get round to commenting during the challenge, but this was one of my highest scoring images. Love it.

in peace...
by edmeng

Comment:
This did not score anything like as high as I thought it would. Love it.