Balconies and Windows
by Lydia

Comment:
I like this image but feel it could have benefitted from a polarizing filter to remove (or at least reduce) the reflections.

1000 piece make one big circle
by sjshaf

Comment:
I like the colors of the puzzle and the subtle use of DOF. It feels like the white balance is slightly off, giving the photo a slight yellowish tinge. Also, while I understand you showed the edge, to demonstrate the circular form of the puzzle, the brownish bit at the bottom tends to draw the eye away from the puzzle itself.

Smile and the world smiles with you.
by roz

Comment:
Nice sharp focus overall. The tight crop works well for the challenge.

Great-Grandfather's Edge - Still True
by fisherfoto

Comment:
Nice use of the sepia tone. Love the DOF on this.

yum
by kichu

Comment:
I like this image, although I don't personally feel that a repeating pattern meets the challenge brief of filling the frame with a subject. I still gave this a 7, since I like the colors, the DOF and the pastries look delicious :-)

Precision from Another Era
by arngrimurbl

Comment:
Interesting image! I like the use of the sepia tone here.

Encased
by Hauxon

Comment:
Very nice portrait! The sharp focus on the eyes, draws one into the image. Well done!

Acuity
by kanaj

Comment:
One of my favorites for a ribbon this week! Very nice!

To The Stars
by lovemelvin

Comment:
One of my favorite images for this challenge! Very nice B&W portrait!

I hold your hand in mine, dear ...
by GeneralE

Comment:
Not sure if the dark and grainy effect is intentional, but the lack of highlights makes the image appear flat.