Come back next weekend
by sandeep_tata

Comment:
An OK image but there are others in this challenge with the same theme that have been executed slightly better. In this nothing seems to be in focus well: 6

Last Game of the Season
by hudson

Comment:
Nice image with good focus on the lock. The way the purples are the only colour is very nice (selective desat or were they the natural colours?): 7

Cast from The Garden
by visionist

Comment:
Two things here I have to give you the benefit of the doubt on; 1. is this a sporting venue? 2. are these people players or spectators?

Assuming the image passes both these tests then it's not DNMC so I'll vote on that basis...

The lights behind the person in front make his arm appear to disappear and the whole image could do with a levelling up. I like the border as it works well with the B&W: 5

Fallen Captains
by Sunshyne

Comment:
Meets challenge and is a good idea. Were the statues supposed to be centered in the posts? 6

First Base
by senor_kasper

Comment:
I like the idea - a good unique take on the challenge. Why did you cut off the top of the tractor though? That makes the image feel like something is missing: 6

Lets celebrate my victory
by Simpa

Comment:
A good moody feel with the lighting and the composition is good as the table seems to form a "V" to pull my eye to the candle in the middle. I'd give this a 6 or 7 normally but as the challenge said "photograph a sporting venue after the game is over" and there is no indication the table was the venue DNMC=3

Praying Player
by jstnknight

Comment:
The image istelf is good but too tightly cropped on the right as the players foot is cut off. I presume selective desat to keep the red - if so then that is done well. The sadu bit is that as the challenge said "the players and people have gone home" I have to DNMC this: 3 - sorry :(

After it's all said & done
by ace flyman

Comment:
Not a unique concept but this is well executed. There is a lot going on in the frame but I'm not too distracted from the bat and gear. A tiny bit cropped off the right would help: 7

Innocent eyes
by chandram

Comment:
An OK image in itself but I fail to see the link with the topic. A 6 or 7 normally but DNMC=3

Forgotten
by DJWoodward

Comment:
A good concept at it meets challenge. I like the unique POV but I think that it is that POV that also hurts this image. By shooting from low the background details like the posts get lost in the sky a bit. I also feel the lighting is a bit harsh on the boots: 6