the white horse
by posthumous

Comment:
Lovely landscape that shows you *can* use portrait framing successfully. I would have used a different title as this one draws attention to a small speck of a horse when, IMHO, the grandeur of the storm clouds is the subject.

From Death
by SherwinJames

Comment:
I'd say "b) The photo presented conflicting thoughts or messages, and voters were left unsure of what to comment."

I find the photo unpleasant. Unattractive colors. Seeds that look like raisins. Foreground that is OOF and blown. But the title would imply that was what you were trying to achieve.

It is surprising that you didn't get any comments on this.

Oh! What a Lovely War
by SteveDunster

Comment:
Why the overexposure and glare?

The Shining ... Heeere's Johnny
by inanutshell

Comment:
Nice to see "Wendy" in the picture as well. COuld have used less light on her side of the door.

Field of Dreams - "If you build it... they will come"
by NstiG8tr

Comment:
Good job. Leaves me wondering how you built it at got them to come in a weeks time. :-)

Charlie Chaplin "The Golden Rush"
by LevT

Comment:
Great staging. Very realistic. Hope you do well!

Somewhere in Time
by wtirado

Comment:
Ah, yes, the only scene I remember from that movie! I think the penny could be sharper, though.

The Shining
by Nunni

Comment:
Effective and memorable.

Willy Wonka & the Chocolate Factory
by scalvert

Comment:
Good shot and shows much preparation (hard to find one of those Wonka bars with the prize ticket).

Guess Who's Coming to Dinner?
by slickshooter

Comment:
Somehow, I don't think so. Nice capture with plenty of color, but just not for this challenge.