Daylight Robbery
by Agaricus

Comment:
Cute, but I think the small canvas size is hurting you.

Shannons
by jeffzoet

Comment:
I liked her better all cut up in polaroids... Nice lighting though.

Evening at Sleaford
by John White

Comment:
One of those "one picture" triptychs. I like this one. I busted someone else for a 3D border, but I think it works here. 7

Bad Santa
by beautyqn25

Comment:
Ha, love it. The center panel is priceless. 9 If I have a beef, there is slightly too much reflection on his torso. You might have been able to lower that by using a different channel mixer ratio.

For Any Mood
by karmat

Comment:
I like it. A good "advertising" theme. The colors and lighting are superb. 8

Going Out
by mandyturner

Comment:
Neat idea. I think the crops bewteen the center and right picture are unfortunate. The line which starts down her jaw (in the right panel) seemingly curves up the other side of her face (in the center panel). This makes the brain try to "put the face together" and of course that doesn't work.

Devotion
by sajin

Comment:
Nice. Tigers are so gorgeous. I think this works well as a triptych telling a story. 8

Aerial Ballet
by Riponlady

Comment:
I like this. Only beef is the slightly different exposure on the left. But this was a hard challenge to get things exaclty right (I don't think I did). The symmetry is nice. The gulls look a little blue though. 7

Night shift
by caba

Comment:
Hmmm, wonderful picture. I'll give you points for creativity, but ultimately I don't think I like the cat's eyes. 6

goodbye
by Tammer

Comment:
I didn't look at the comments before leaving my own. I gave this a 6 in the original voting. I think the composition is good with the Father being at the bottom. However, a tigher crop so there is less grass may have been good. Cut the picture just above the top of the leaves. You get grass to the left, but not too much. I'd also add just a touch more stone beneath the Father.

I'm finding a common theme among these pictures I'm commenting on and that is low contrast. I went into photoshop and think this pic has much more pop if you go into levels and change them to 20/1.00/215. This, in essence, adds contrast and I think it looks better.