Looking Inside & Outside
by 777STAN

Comment:
I like the idea you hade here, but I think that he bright white circle is far too distracting. Composing a little differently and exposing a little longer would have made this one a contender. Great detail with the dirty window and nice focus.

On the Other Side
by MartinKemp

Comment:
My first consideration was that this is more of a reflection than a frame. Looking closer, I see that it is both. I think that I would have cropped her a little differently to get her out of the center, but nice capture overall.

Room With a View
by margiemu

Comment:
Nice idea, and this one has lots of potential. First of all, keep the image as large as possible dimension-wise when posting it. I think a shift in your position to get more of the snow-capped mountains woudl have been a great improvement. I am positive that I want to live there.

San Francisco
by bryanbrazil

Comment:
I like the coloring and the depth of field you achieved with this shot. I think backing up a bit and getting more of the window frame itself owuld have improved this one. Good eye.

Impact
by messerschmitt

Comment:
Your focus and exposure are near flawless, but I get a more window-lit feeling to this one than a window-framed. Perhaps cropping tighter on the man and getting him out of the center of the fram would have improved it for this particular challenge. All of the elements fit with each other very well, just not for this challenge.

The vase
by train

Comment:
Nicely composed and captured. The tonal range is nicely covered and the crutain really leads the eye around the frame. Nicely seen.

Passenger Window
by amyr37

Comment:
These are always some of my favorite shots, as I have taken way too many of them. However, this really doesn't give me a feeling of looking through a window at a subject. The composition and exposure are near flawless, but it really doesn't meet the challenge in my opinion.

Busted
by LevT

Comment:
Great idea, but the couple is a little too centered. I like the way your lighting makes the almost jump out of the frame. Great expressions, and beautiful flexibility. ;)

View From the Chicken Coupe at Sunset
by jbsmithana

Comment:
Well-done. I like the way the screen provides a captured feel to the image. I think that I may have shifted my position a bit to get the barn more out of the center, but nice capture overall. The tulips lead my eye trough the shot and to the barn very well, then the barn up to the sky. Good eye.

Lonely tree
by alexgarcia

Comment:
I think you picked a perfect window for framing, but there is really no subject other than the window itself. Nice focus and good exposure, but I think that there needs to be something other than the distant tree in the frame.