Hope it's the red one
by bullethead

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

I remember this shot from the challenge well. By far the best wire-cutting shot. You kept it simple, clean and colorful. Very nice composition. I like the lines a lot too - they lead the eye right into the decision portrayed in this picture.

It met the challenge perfectly and is a very nice shot on its own. The background is a little noisy & distracting, but only slightly so. The detail you managed to eke out on the wirecutters is great. Lighting is also very good - very little glare (with the exception of the background, and I'm not sure how you could cut down on that noise unless you did it selectively). And by sticking with very basic colors in the wires, you really accented the overall feel with the color.

Very nice job. Sorry I don't have more critical suggestions to make, but I think you nailed this one right on!

Just my 2 cents... :-)

Jimmy

Of Shoes
by Simonkasprzak

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

You really did capture an intangible decision exquisitely. The pose of the feet are perfect to create the scenario of indecision. The composition is terrific - I like the way the shot is cropped. The lighting, however, is a little harsh (too bright). I think you could reduce some of the backlighting and play with the contrast a little more to really bring out more detail and a warmer glow to the overall scene.

I also think you could get a little more pizzazz out of the colors represented by adjusting the saturation. If you're going for a muted color shot, then I still think this is true. The colors are a bit washed out by the lighting, so the combination of working on the lighting & the colors (IMHO) could make the shot even more powerful.

You really did a beautiful job with this setup. Again, you created an immediate sense of what was going on in the scene. That alone is something to be very proud of. It's not easy to evoke emotions from your viewer so quickly. Great job!

Just my 2 cents...

Jimmy

Mom, should I turn left or right at the 3rd corner?
by Gauti

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

I think you did a wonderful job creating a vast expanse with your composition. The road leads you into the shot very nicely and the closeness/familiarity of the model/phone/car are all something that is easy for people to identify with. The road really draws your eye to the sky and landscape - and the sky is fantastic!

The car & model seem to be a bit grainy and dark (which I think detracts a bit from the overall image), but you did a great job creating a "real" feeling/scenario. I think you could increase the lighting for the entire shot a hair or two - to bring out more detail in the foreground and midground. Perhaps reducing the backlighting a touch and adjusting the contrast? This would reduce some of the glare on the car door while increasing some of the detail on the car itself.

Just my 2 cents, but I thought this image was great in the challenge - I know it scored high marks with me. Again, I just have to say that the sky is a masterpiece... Nice work!

Jimmy

Fire Waiting To Pour
by benlenz

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

First of all, I'd like to say that this is an unusually captivating sunset shot! I love the colors and reflections. The colors seem natural and not overprocessed (which is a real compliment these days!).

Secondly, I'd like to add that I think the focus could be better overall. I understand that in these types of shots, clarity is not necessarily the foremost thought (and shouldn't necessarily be), but I think that the lack of focus on the "mainland" is a little distracting. Don't get me wrong, it is still pretty good, I just think that is one area in which you might be able to improve on an already good image.

Thirdly, I'd suggest a different crop on this particular image. The real focus and meaning (IMHO) of this shot is the sunset, so why not crop out some of the incidental landscape on the bottom of the shot. It doesn't really add to the image - it's mostly dark anyway. I think you should leave just enough of the "land" to elicit a feeling of "earth", then concentrate on the beautiful spectacle that is the sunset and it's radiant colors.

I think you have two routes that you could go here... One is embracing the vastness of the sky and capitalizing on its various colors and brightness; the other is cropping out everything above the dark clouds you already have oulined in your color saturation selections.

Either way, I think you can improve on the impact your image represents by bringing out those warm sunset tones in the particular areas you choose to show.

Please don't get me wrong... I think that your current image has a LOT of merit and is extremely pleasing AS IS. I'm just trying to constructively comment on an already pleasant picture.

Just my 2 cents...

Jimmy

My Bug
by Neuferland

Comment:
Absolutely adorable shot! I have to ask though... Is he a Silky or is he a Chinese Crested? He looks remarkably like some of the Chinese Cresteds I've been reviewing (I can't believe I'm saying this, but I really want one! LOL).

Really nice use of lighting and sepia tones. It created a very warm setting for your love. I'm jealous & want one now! LOL

Thanks for sharing such an intimate part of your life with us. I only hope that WHEN I have such a soulmate I will be willing to share him/her as well...

PICT6477.JPG
by BigR

Comment:
Nice composition and subject placement in this shot, but the glare is a bit overwhelming. I think if you were to reduce the backlighting/midtones/highlights/contrast, you would find that you could bring out more detail in the "light" areas of this photo. That would make it more balanced and allow the natural elements present in the shot to speak for themselves.

Just my 2 cents...

Jimmy

PICT6437.JPG
by BigR

Comment:
The glare from the light on the left is distracting. I like the pose and expression of the model, but I think it could be even more impactful if the highlights were toned down a bit. For example, I think her lime green shirt and blue fingernails could really be augmented to enhance the overall effect and "feel" of the shot - making it not only more personal, but more universally appealing as well.

Again, just my 2 cents...

Jimmy

PICT6431.JPG
by BigR

Comment:
Very cute pic! I really like the fact that he has on red shorts as well!

The little boy obviously loves trains (despite the Spider-Man shirt) - and I think that feeling really comes through in the photograph. I think you might be able to tone down some of the glare with some reduction of backlighting and/or contrast. I use MS Digital Photo Suite (as opposed to PS), but I'm sure there are equivalents in most post-processing packages.

I think the composition and colors are excellent. The clarity is also good - although not quite as strong as the content. The lighting is probably the most obvious element to me that could use a little improvement. I think if you experiment a little with it and contrast, you'll be able to even further improve the quality of the shot.

Overall, a very nice photo.

Just my 2 cents...

Jimmy

Green eyes
by LevT

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

First of all, let me say that this is truly a beautiful shot! Well done.

Some of my comments would include:
*I can't tell that her eyes are truly green (they look brown to me), so I would probably either change the title or adjust the color saturation.
*The lighting on her face is a little dark. I think you could increase this selectively during post-processing in whatever your application of choice may be.
*I really like the overall lighting of the shot. The hair's a bit messy, but that happens... ;-)
*You managed to catch a good expression (full of mystery) in the model's face.
*I think you made good use of the blurred background effect. Oftentimes this is overused/misused, but you used it both tastefully and in a manner that added to the overall feeling of your image.
*This may sound like an odd question, but did you happen to remove something (or some things) from the floorboard of the pier in the background? I only ask because of the periodic apparent "holes" in the silhouette of the pier's floor. It's not a big deal, but I did notice it and wonder what was up...
*Overall, a very nicely composed & executed shot. I think you could benefit from some additional postprocessing of the image, but that's really a very minor point.

Nice job & a beautiful shot to share - thank you!

Just my 2 cents...

sunshine
by sigrun_th

Comment:
* Greetings from the Critique Club *

Boy, is this a difficult image to comment on... It's beautiful, please don't get me wrong. It's extremely well composed and the colors are very life-like (not overdone as many images are).

I do have to say though, that the blurriness of the background images is a little distracting (although I realize that they were probably done that way purposefully), and that the sky is a little drab. You could probably punch up the sky colors with some selective processing (if you want your image to appear that way - I'm certainly no expert, but I do know what I like). The most important thing to remember is what YOU feel and what YOU like about the shot.

There are portions of this image that seem abnormally sharp to me (namely the girl and some of the foreground) - did you happen to selectively increase that level of contrast & sharpness? If so, I think you might be better off with a more even-handed approach to this particular shot. (I know that in many instances you want to selectively sharpen, but I'm not sure that it works in your favor in this particular case.)

It really is a beautiful setting & a well-composed shot. Nice job.

Just my 2 cents... :-)

Jimmy