15.jpg
by rasdub

Comment:
Great tones here - and I even like the fisheye effect (not always a plus for me). Beautiful scene and you really captured it well - good focus, composition, & processing.

OMG
by Amason

Comment:
Holy crap! I'm so glad I stumbled across this shot while looking through rasdub's Favorites! This is really incredible! You made the right choice editing... "what houses?!?" I don't see anything but an amazing display of nature's beauty well captured by someone with an obviously very good eye. My newest Favorite...

Just in Time for Breakfast
by dwolff

Comment:
I've only ever seen 2 before in my life and of course I wasn't into photography then (and I probably wouldn't have had my camera with me anyway!). This is such a cool capture! You even managed to work in a nice composition - I'm impressed! Great job!

Branches...
by Skip

Comment:
Very cool shot - love the effects. Would this have been legal in basic editing? (I know I ran into that problem with some of my potential entries.) Love the dreamy feel. I would have scored it a 7.

branchouttake.jpg
by fstopopen

Comment:
Really nice shot! Love the tones. Good composition and pretty good lighting (I realize in basic editing, there's a lot you can't fix - like the washed out areas of the sky/background). I'd have probably scored it a 6-7.

EDIT: Sorry, didn't read the whole thread. I realize now you probably used the dodge brush to lighten the center. Personally, I think it would be better without the haloed glow.

Message edited by author 2005-09-07 21:06:29.

Look
by saintaugust

Comment:
This is really great! The angle and crop IMHO make this shot. Sure the lighting, tones, and high key look are good, but it's the perspective you've created that really gives this image its emotion and visual impact. Very nice work.

Close Call
by arnit

Comment:
This is really a great shot! Fantastic stop action with vivid contrasts and tones. Exceptional clarity and lighting too (in what I'm sure was less than ideal conditions). Very good work.

Black & White Motion
by loriprophoto

Comment:
Beautiful horse - with bizarrely fascinating eyes. Great composition and overall feel to the shot, but the glare from the left side of the horse is a little strong IMHO. I know it's supposed to be high contrast, but I think it only needs to be as light as the dark areas are black. Still overall very strong entry.

contrasting element
by thorgils

Comment:
Really beautiful composition and lighting. There appears to be an odd shaped lighter area around some of the objects (that looks like processing remnants) that is distracting, but that's really the only thing I can find negative about the shot. Very nice job overall.

Asymetrical
by Telehubbie

Comment:
What great lines and composition! Really beautiful job here. My only suggestion would be to perhaps make the black border more of a dark silver to match some of the tones in the image. Otherwise, great job!