One tree hill
by Neat

Comment:
A beautifully composed shot enhanced by processing. A beauty. You have such an excellent eye for dark dreamy images, and you have done well carving out a unique niche in the top tier of the challenges often heavy with glossy, staged shot. Congratulations on finishing in the top 10 three years running. Art judged by the masses seems so fickle to me -- consistent high finishes is quite an accomplishment.

Lulu and the Elephant
by RKT

Comment:
Delightful image.

The Elegance of The Fall
by Oz

Comment:
Sweet image, Oz. congrats on the bling and great finish.

Serenity
by pamb

Comment:
Awesome finish, Pam. Great image and sweet finish.

~ S ~
by Ja-9

Comment:
Awesome, Janine. Way to go.

Swirling humanity
by Melethia

Comment:
Hmmmm... I like this one, too. It has a much different mood to it with the bustling crowd. The title fits the mood well. Maybe it would have scored better?

Ascending
by Melethia

Comment:
This was the one you mentioned wanting feedback on during voting, right? I would have been no help.
I liked this one -- scored it a 7. You eventually got some nice comments -- not sure why it didn't score better.

Gray Line
by nygold

Comment:
OK, to me this clearly deserved better than a 5.6 and a single comment. I really enjoy the colors and motion in this, and I like the b&w guy with his face half out of frame. Nice shot.

in stride
by PennyStreet

Comment:
Congrats on the PH Yellow. I found this one fascinating.

Central
by Oz

Comment:
What do I know? I gave this an 8. I liked the framing with motion one side and static the other.