1
by sevilduvarci

Comment:
Not really sure about this image, I think I find the gentleman sitting down on our left to have the most character, and may perhaps a better shot of him would be fantastic. Maybe what it is, is this shot is straight out the doors... I think a sharp angle to out the doors with the open doors not being center frame but to the side would make this a much stronger image.

Fire Door
by jackal9

Comment:
I like this idea for the shot, it is a touched oversharped, or least that halow around it is a bit of a distraction. Also I would have liked to see this more vertical or a harsher angle, here for me it just doesn't look like the slight tilt is on purpose. Something looks a touch off on the bg as well... just odd.

Day 1 - Ev
by jonfrommk

Comment:
It is a fantastic shot of your friend, I really enjoy the half capture. But for my preference I would enjoy a bit more contrastiness in the image. It just really seems a bit flat.

DAY 1. B&W. full moon ..
by roz

Comment:
Shots like this... when seen in person will blow you away. However, even I have been guilty of coming back and finding out I didn't get exactly what I was seeing. I like and don't like the post in the front, what I don't like is the position it is in, but I do like the large object there. And unless you could move the cross post, not much you can do about that. I like the down angle on the cross post, but would have liked to see the main post vertical. The fade of the sky is just unreal I really enjoy this setup... but, I really also wish the moon wasn't just a bright spot. Personally I might have just cloned out the moon and left the sky it is fantastic.

Strong
by Retroesque

Comment:
The lines of the building are very nice, but I am wondering about maybe a stronger angle (you closer to the building) and a different part of day, so the gradulant of the light on the building is gone. For me it just doesn't balance the image very well. Personally I also think the sky is a bit dark. However I find that tree marvelous beyond compare.

Men Are Dogs II - XVI
by SJCarter

Comment:
I really like the post processing here, the colours are just fantastic as are the textures.

The Composite itself I believe you did a fantastic job of combining the two images, yet, the perspective seems a bit off in my opinion. It looks good, but something about the positioning of the snout just looks off a touch. Maybe Im wrong, but it takes away from the overall feel of the image.

As I continue to look at the image, I am starting to believe that white highlight on the snout is throwing off the lighting continuity for the image and that is what was bothering me so much. To me the main light source seems to be coming from behind your right shoulder (left side of image) and the extremely bright highlight on the snout is out of place. There is no other highlight in the image that matches that intensity.

Men Are Dogs - XV
by SJCarter

Comment:
I really enjoy the personification you created with mans best friend and yourself. I really enjoy the overall processing and feel of this image. I don't really think there is anything bad I can say about it. You did a really great job here.

So I will get a little nit picky, by the right ear it is a touch blown out, I think cloning a bit of hair there would really even out the head area. easy fix, and maybe making the soul patch a bit bigger, so it stands out just a touch better. But like I said, thats being nit picky L()L... Great job.

Dreams of Refreshment
by Greetmir

Comment:
This shot has so much WOWOWOWWOWOW potential. I really love the glass, the effects are just mind bogglingly fantastic. The base has to be my absolute favorite part Perfectly oozy. (-;. The Rim is also very fantastic. But, I think you went overboard with the lemon. I would love to see a perfectly intact lemon on this warped glass. I think also keeping the plastic wrap on the inside edge of the lemon would be great and the effect lessens as it goes to the outside.

I really enjoy the green and yellow I think the shades and brightnesses are fantastic, however, I am wondering what if the background was brighter? I would love to see this with all black, and all white variants to really see how the effect changes.

You did a great job here... Just pushed the rules to far and they broke 6-; Nice image (-; and rules are made to be broken.

Enchanted Forest
by elsapo

Comment:
There is just something here that really throws me. I enjoy the effects and textures of the image. The leaves on the ground to the trees reaching out. The model I think the model and wings or the wings more so throw me, as well as the transition of colours from the ground to the sky.

Possible idea, change the perspective of the wings to be more forward instead of the pined to the wall look. Also, I would really like to see the colours reversed here. Blues on the ground and yellows in the sky. With that bright light I would think it would create a whole new element for the image. Lastly, I think the little sparkles on the dress are a bit of a distraction. They don't seem to hold a continuity with the rest of the image.

It is a very nice image overall, but I am curious to see it redone.

Realm of Fairies
by elsapo

Comment:
I look at this and find a beautiful image, However, I also see an obviously manipulated image. What I think breaks the fantasy feel for this image, is the smoothness of the water over the rocks. If, there was a more illustrative feel to the rapids, I think this picture would be award winning. I really enjoy the colours of the trees, the fairy and orbs are nice. But, for me the water takes me away from the imaginary.