Padlock
by JoseArtist

Comment:
Composition: 5, I feel you are too centered and too straight on
Technical: 9
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 8, subject a little weak as there are many things that show more mechanical attributes.
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

mechanics of a toilet
by lightning

Comment:
Composition: 1, Needs to show more of the workings.
Technical: 7, Nice lighting.
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 1
Overall Calculated Average Score: 3, Without the title I think it misses completely the challenge.

Chaindrive
by matispista

Comment:
Composition: 10, Nice job cute and interesting angle.
Technical: 10, focus,DOF and light perfect.
Appeal: 10
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 10, Very interesting concept with the chain and the coil.

Scramble 'em
by shamel

Comment:
Composition: 9, Simple and a story to boot.
Technical: 7, A little work with the lighting could do wonders here.
Appeal: 7
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

Computer's grandfather
by yoman

Comment:
Composition: 5, Back drops are a bummer. Maybe if you had draped the sheet so it would have been continuous, without the break between table and wall, it might become more a photograph. Looks more like just another typewriter this way.
Technical: 4
Appeal: 3
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 6, Be nice to add a secretary typing.

unstopable
by leifur

Comment:
Composition: 7, I don't get the relationship between the ruler and the watch...Is it just measurement?
Technical: 8
Appeal: 4
Challenge: 8, I'll bet the watch has a battery!
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

"Old School"
by cwalmye

Comment:
Composition: 8, Might use additional prop for more interest, pencil etc.
Technical: 8, Like sepia, but a bit dark in shadowed areas. Blends in with BG too much.
Appeal: 6
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 8

Manual Stapler
by birdyblue

Comment:
Composition: 5, Too much neg space and the staples should be identical. Almost looks like a malfunction.
Technical: 8
Appeal: 5
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

Gateway
by sher

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 6, A little flat, needs more contrast to me.
Appeal: 6
Challenge: 9
Overall Calculated Average Score: 7

Critter
by anireno

Comment:
Composition: 8
Technical: 8, Hot spots just a little too hot. BG could be a little more colorful.
Appeal: 8
Challenge: 10
Overall Calculated Average Score: 9