Stuff Magazine - or - Playboy
by DrJOnes

Comment:
Very good skin tones, lots of vavva-va-voom! 10 Rob the Swash

"DOG WORLD"
by melissarts

Comment:
Pretty sky...but the lighting on the dog isn't very complimentary, the partial silhouette shows a few of the dog's features, so it doesn't work as either a good look of the dog or a good silhouette. The sharpness seems low. Back to the lighting...the sun pretty much washed out the sky in that area. 5 Rob the Swash

Fashion
by TonesOfGray

Comment:
Nice shot for focus, but the lighting is very harsh on the model\'s chest, hand and leg. Nice angle approach. 6 Rob the Swash

Rubber Lover
by ish36

Comment:
???? I've never heard of that magazine (but I won't score you down for it). The pattern is nice, but the lack of sharpness hurts the overall image. Nice color and lack of hot glare spots. 6 Rob the Swash

Wildlife Conservation....http://wcs.org/
by Gracious

Comment:
Beautiful shot! The bird seems a tad overly sharp, but I like this image so very much. Love the color. Nice amount of open spaces for type (nit, but worth commenting). A tad faster exposure might have stopped the leg motion. Still, I love this, so 10 - Rob the Swash

Bird Watcher's Digest
by TerryGee

Comment:
Amazing photo!!! The wren looked almost wooden (but it's too good for that even). Even more incredible with the ant in it's beak. WOW!!! Great color, focus and I like the framing - but the square sizing might hurt your overall score (but not from me!!) 10 Rob the Swash

Great Break Time
by kposey

Comment:
This seems more like a picture of a magazine cover, rather than a picture FOR a magazine cover. Very clear, well taken photo. Good color. 5 Rob the Swash

In between somewhere..
by Michael_

Comment:
Nice colors, but the trees seem pretty blurry. The title doesn't seem to be a magazine title, what mag were you "covering"? I just don't get it, sorry, my bad.
4 Rob the Swash

Real Simple
by BeingClever

Comment:
Its a very good photo (though a bit less than appealing), but I don\'t get it. I\'ve never heard of Real Simple mag and I\'m not coming up with any mag title that would put this on their cover (Maybe a fruit drying mag?) The layout doesn\'t seem to lend itself to a cover shot, too (but I\'m not really scoring that issue). 4 Rob the Swash

National Geographic
by ashwin

Comment:
Lovely photo, but I think you missed the challenge idea - Make your OWN mag cover, not shoot somebody else's (this is other people's art - site rules and all)
4 Rob the Swash